f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 17, 2026 6:06 pm PDT

In May of 2021, I had the absolute honor of interviewing Indians legend Rocky Colavito in an unforgettable installment of Spitballin’. Colavito’s career spanned from 1955-1968 so he got to see a great generation of post-WWII pitchers in the twilights of their careers and the up-and-coming young hurlers who would become superstars on the mound in the 1970s and 80’s.

When I asked Colavito who the best pitcher he ever saw was, he had no shortage of folks to choose from. If he wanted to go old school, he faced guys like Whitey Ford, Jim Bunning and Robin Roberts. Those horses of the ‘70s included Tom Seaver, Nolan Ryan and Jim Palmer among others.

So when it came down to it, who did Colavito choose?

His own teammate, Herb Score.

Shocked? You shouldn’t be.

Score and Colavito were teammates in 1954 in AAA, so Rocky got to see Score before he burst onto the scene as a rookie in 1955. As a 21-year-old in AAA, Score went 22-5 with a 2.62 ERA with an astounding 330 strikeouts in 251 innings. Score was named The Sporting News Minor League Pitcher of the Year and called a lefty Bob Feller.

Score continued his dominance in 1955 when he shattered the rookie record for strikeouts with 245. That number might not seem totally insane by today’s standards, but it was truly absurd for his time. The prior mark was set by baseball immortal Pete Alexander in 1911 with 227. However, Alexander needed 367 innings to reach that total while Score reached 245 K’s in 140 less innings.

Score was the only rookie between Alexander’s 1911 season and Dwight Gooden’s 1984 season to strike out 200 batters in a season and he hit that milestone before the end of August.

Score followed his 1955 Rookie of the Year season by taking another step forward in ’56. Now 23, Score went 20-9 with a 2.53 ERA and 263 strikeouts in 249 innings. The young infusion of talent was just what the Indians needed for their pitching staff, which included Hall of Famers Feller, Bob Lemon and Early Wynn, who were all over 35 years old.

The fateful 1957 season started off great for Score, who continued to blaze through the American League through his first four starts. He allowed just three earned runs over his first 33 innings while striking out 35. All seemed peachy until the night of May 7 – a night that changed the trajectory of baseball history and lands in this week’s installment of The Stud 400.

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

225: Cy Young wins #511 (1911)

224: Dodgers & Red Sox play longest postseason game (2018)

223: Game 7 of the 1924 World Series (1924)

222: Earl Weaver vs. Bill Haller (1980)

221: Ted Williams homers on eephus pitch (1946)

And now, here’s Episode XXXVII of The Stud 400.

220. Bobby Bonilla Day (2000)

To most Mets fans, Bobby Bonilla’s deferred contract situation has become a tired joke. Bonilla didn’t grab the first or last deferred contract. He wasn’t the biggest name to get a deferred contract and it’s certainly not the biggest one either. It was more a perfect storm of personalities and ineptitude. The Wilpon ownership era for the Mets is not looked upon kindly, and that’s putting it nicely. They were so cheap at times that Fred Wilpon was referred to as “Fred Coupon.” Once the Bernie Madoff scandal hit, that was just another giant notch in the mosaic that painted the Wilpons as inept. With Wilpon’s reputation already in the gutter, Bonilla’s deferred contract terms somehow made their way to the public eye and it just seemed to absurd right from the start.

Instead of paying the $5.9 million remaining on Bonilla’s contract, the Mets agreed to pay Bonilla $1.2 million every year on July 1 at 8% interest. That would come out to a total of $29.8 million. The Wilpons counted on the return on investments with Madoff to essentially pay that off. As with many things with the Mets and Wilpon, things went south and got ugly fast.

For years, it seemed that Bonilla was the only player in baseball history with a deferred contract, and on July 1 every year, it became a fun tradition for the baseball world to point their fingers at the Mets and laugh. In all actuality, it had been going on for decades prior. In fact, part of Darryl Strawberry’s 1985 Mets contract was deferred and will be paid through 2033! Other big name retired players with deferred contracts include Bruce Sutter, Ken Griffey Jr. and Manny Ramirez. However, to this day, Bonilla remains the face of the deferred contract and with the Mets under new ownership, it has become more of a fun type of farce instead of a black eye on the franchise, even if Bonilla will remain on the Mets payroll until he’s 72 years old.


219. Roberto Alomar spitting incident (1996)

By 1996, Roberto Alomar was well on his way to nailing down his candidacy as a Hall of Fame second baseman. He was in the prime of his career and at the age of 28, he was already a two-time World Series champ, seven time All-Star, seven-time Gold Glove winner and had won two Silver Slugger Awards. For the most part, he was a quiet superstar who played a sublime second base, was an excellent baserunner and a dynamic switch hitter. On September 27, 1996, Alomar got into an argument with home plate umpire John Hirschbeck over a 3-2 strike that was admittedly outside. Alomar had words with Hirschbeck on his walk from the batter’s box to the dugout, and Hirschbeck promptly tossed Alomar. A heated Alomar returned to home plate and as much as Orioles manager Davey Johnson tried to intervene, he couldn’t calm Alomar.

We used to do our own lip reading back in the day, and it was clear to all that Alomar repeatedly said, “F— You!” to Hirschbeck multiple times before spitting directly in his face. After the game, Alomar claimed that Hirschbeck said a racial slur, which set him off. Alomar also opined that Hirschbeck was probably bitter because one of his sons died of a rare disease and his other son had the same disease as well. Yikes. Hirschbeck had to be physically restrained from attacking Alomar in the locker room after he learned of the comments. The ugly situation resulted in Alomar being suspended for five games and making a $50,000 donation towards ALD research, the disease which afflicted Hirschbeck’s sons. On April 22, 1997, both were involved in a game for the first time since the incident and shook hands at home plate prior to the game.


218. Eric Gregg’s giant strike zone (1997)

Everyone complains about umpires. It’s one of the tired tropes in baseball and as soon as the robot umpires take over, everyone will complain about the robot umpires too. Many times, a particularly bad performance by an umpire will elicit a comparison to Eric Gregg’s performance as the home plate umpire for Game 5 of the 1997 NLCS between the Marlins and Braves. During the game, Gregg was quite generous—putting it mildly—in calling the outside strike to left-handed batters. This was particularly beneficial to Marlins starter Livan Hernandez as the Braves had six lefties in their lineup. Hernandez ended up with 15 strikeouts and the Braves staff combined for 10 more K’s. Eight of the 25 total strikeouts were looking, including the final out of the game, when Fred McGriff was punched out on a curve ball that he couldn’t hit with a telephone pole. The Marlins won Game 5, 2-1, on a three-hitter by Hernandez to go up 3-2 in the series. They would win Game 6 and then topped the favored Indians in a seven-game classic World Series.


217. Herb Score hit with a comebacker (1957)

Score had lit the American League on fire in his first two seasons as a record-setting flamethrower and through four starts in 1957, it was more of the same. Baseball simply had not seen a power pitcher start his career the way Score did, perhaps ever. Even teammate Bob Feller’s early years didn’t match what Score did. It all came crashing down in the first inning of Score’s fifth start in 1957. After retiring Hank Bauer, Score threw a low fastball to the next batter, Gil McDougald, who smoked a line drive towards the tall lefty. It was hit so hard that Score couldn’t get his glove up in time and the ball horrifically careened unadulterated into Score’s face, shattering facial bones and severely damaging his eye.

The injury was so horrific, McDougald didn’t even run toward first; instead sprinting to the mound as Score went down in a heap. Third basemen Al Smith picked up the ball and threw to first for the out. The damage to Score’s face and eye was so severe, he missed the rest of the season and was never the same again. Before the injury, Score was a pitcher the likes of which Major League Baseball had rarely seen. After the injury, Score went 17-26 with a 4.43 in 77 games spread over five partial seasons. Common thought places much of the blame for Score’s downfall on the comebacker, although Score attributes it to an arm injury and subsequent motion change. Either way, one of the most promising careers in baseball history turned into one of the game’s greatest “what if” careers on that fateful night in 1957.


216. MLB begins instant replay (2008)

MLB instant replay was approved for use in Major League Baseball on August 28, 2008 and has been quite prevalent in the sport since then, even if that wasn’t its intended use. When making the announcement, then-Commissioner Bud Selig said, “I believe that the extraordinary technology that we now have merits the use of instant replay on a very limited basis. The system we have in place will ensure that the proper call is made on home run balls and will not cause a significant delay to the game.” Yeah, right. That may have been the intention at the time, but as BallNine’s own Kevin Kernan says, there are always unintended consequences. Replay has grown from its original iteration of being used only on borderline home run calls to dissecting plays down to fractions of inches with plenty of delays in the game. Like it or not though, it was a major change in the way the game is played and umpired – and when a call is overturned in your favorite team’s favor, you’re pretty damn happy that it was put in place.


Stay tuned for the next episode of The Stud 400 when we go to the videotape, examine one of the most infamous postseason performances ever and revisit one of the great “what if” careers. You’ll be spittin’ mad if you miss next week’s installment of The Stud 400!

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register