f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 12, 2026 11:42 am PDT

Every so often in The Stud 400, we like to talk about important topics. This week we want to talk to you about protection. You know, if you fail in this area, it’s something you can regret the rest of your life. It could have major impacts – both positive and negative – on many parties so you’d better not mess up.

We are of course talking about the Rule 5 draft. What did you think we meant?

The Rule 5 Draft has happened every year since 1920 and has had multiple incarnations and tweaks over the years. Essentially, unprotected players could be scooped up by rival teams with the caveat that they must remain on the major league active roster for the entire subsequent season. Players who are not on the 40-man roster and fall under certain age and minor league service time guidelines are eligible to be drafted, so it is on the teams to identify those players eligible to be plucked from their organization and make sure they protect the ones they want to keep.

Over the years, there have been plenty of Rule 5 draftees who have made a huge impact on the game. Some Rule 5 names you may recognize include Jose Bautista, Bobby Bonilla, George Bell, Darrell Evans, Johan Santana and a personal favorite of mine, Sal “The Barber” Maglie. It goes so far back that Hall of Famers Christy Mathewson and Hack Wilson were Rule 5 picks!

There have been so many players that make you wonder how in the world an organization could have left them unprotected. Could nobody see the potential in Paul Blair, Willie Hernandez or Kelly Gruber? They may not be Hall of Famers, but those are some damn fine ballplayers.

When it comes to Rule 5 regrets, one team’s failure to use protection stands out above all others: the Brooklyn Dodgers. The 1954 Dodgers were absolutely loaded with legends. You could start at Jackie Robinson and go right on down the line with Duke Snider, Gil Hodges, Roy Campanella and Pee Wee Reese.

At the time, they had a young, 19-year-old outfielder in his first season of AAA that year who they liked, but who hadn’t produced much on the field in what was his first minor league season. Either they didn’t really see a need to protect this youngster who they admitted was strong defensively, or they didn’t think other teams would see the potential in the raw, but gifted player. Whatever the case, they left him unprotected.

That defense-first youngster from Puerto Rico was Roberto Clemente. Imagine a decade of Clemente and Snider playing next to each other? One can dream of what it would have been like to see Clemente on those great Dodgers teams of the 1950s and 60s, but as far as we’re concerned at BallNine, the baseball Gods got this one right. Roberto Clemente would not look right wearing anything except the black and gold of Pittsburgh – and they can thank the Rule 5 Draft and a daft baseball executive named Branch Rickey, yes that Branch Rickey, for swiping Clemente away from the Dodgers.

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

210: Topps gets into baseball cards (1952)

209: Jimmie Foxx’s 500th home run (1940)

208: Lou Brock breaks career stolen base record (1977)

207: Johan Santana’s no-hitter (2012)

206: Mickey Mantle sets career switch hit home run record (1956)

And now, here’s Episode XL of The Stud 400.

205. St. Louis Browns win American League pennant (1944)

The 2024 White Sox are an embarrassment to baseball and the symbol of all of the ineptitude we see in today’s game, but they don’t have anything on the St. Louis Browns franchise. Between 1901-1943, the Browns finished among the bottom three teams in the American League 26 times and finished 10 or more games out of the playoffs 40 of their first 43 years of existence. In 1943, they played their typical brand of poor baseball, finishing sixth out of eight teams, 25 games out of first place. Then the sun shone on the Browns in 1944. They beat out the Tigers by one game to win the American League for the first and only time – but fell to the Cardinals in the World Series.

So what events led to the Browns all of a sudden becoming winners? Smart trades? Development of prospects? Genius management? Nope, that would be World War II. As the joke goes, the Browns were so moribund, even the United States Military didn’t want their players. So while the other teams in baseball were decimated by their young stars going off to war, the Browns had a league-high 13 players who were classified as 4-F, which meant they were unfit for military service. This included shortstop Vern Stephens, a true young star who at 23 years old was the highest-ranked position player in the MVP voting in 1944. Stephens was classified 4-F due to a bad knee and led the team in nearly every offensive category. After a solid 1945, the next eight seasons featured the typical brand of awful Browns baseball until 1954 when the team packed up, moved to Baltimore and became the Orioles.


204. Expos move from Montreal (2004)

There is so much that is so awesome about the Montreal Expos. You can start with logo, the colors, the powder blue uniforms and the exotic nature of being the first Major League team based outside of the United States. Jarry Park was one of the more distinctive—for lack of a better term—modern ballparks and that gave way to Olympic Stadium with its orange dome and concrete turf carpet. Then there were the players. From Rusty Staub, Ron Fairly and Coco Laboy to Warren Cromartie, Ellis Valentine and Pepe Frias, the Expos always had fun guys to root for.

Then there were the legends. We’re talking Tim Raines, Gary Carter, Andre Dawson, Vladimir Guerrero and a young Pedro Martinez. So if everything was so fantastic, how come they no longer exist? That’s too complex a tale to get into here, but the soul of Major League Baseball died a little bit when the Expos packed their bags and moved to Washington. Here’s to hoping that when expansion inevitably happens again, the people of Montreal get their team back and slap that retro classic red, white and blue logo right back in its proper place, as God intended. Vive les Expos!


203. Home plate collisions banned (2014)

Baseball used to be a man’s game. You used to be able to knock a shortstop into left field breaking up two, drill a guy because he sneezed in your direction and partake in a good ol’ fashion bench-clearer without the wrath of overzealous disciplinarians ejecting, suspending and fining anyone who looked sideways at someone. Another physical play that produced some of the most fantastic highlights in the game’s history that has been legislated out of the game is the home plate collision.

Colloquially known as the “Buster Posey Rule,” the initial iteration of the rule intended to protect catchers from being run over when they were unprotected and unprepared for a collision. The language stated, “A runner attempting to score may not deviate from his direct pathway to the plate in order to initiate contact with the catcher.” So basically, if a catcher wanted to protect himself, he could take a step out of the running lane with the idea that the baserunner couldn’t deviate out of his way to plow him into next week. Nobody would argue against it being a well-intended rule. As with all of these rule changes though, unintended consequences followed, and the rule has mutated into a giant grey area where nobody knows what’s what. There have been plenty of runners who would have easily been out who were ruled safe due to plate blocking violations and other plays where a block should have been called when it wasn’t. Nobody is really sure of what will happen on most of these calls, so anytime it goes to replay, it’s a giant crapshoot.


202. MLB adds Wild Card (1994)

Baseball was once the unique sport where the regular season carried so much meaning. When you had to win your division to make the postseason, teams had to approach the regular season with a win-or-bust attitude. As recently as 1993, only the four division winners qualified for the postseason. Baseball fans of that era laughed at sports like the NHL where 16 of 24 teams made the playoffs or the NBA where 16 of the 27 teams qualified. The baseball playoffs were sacred and reserved only for the absolute best of the best; the four best teams that emerged from the marathon season. It was a herculean feat just to qualify for the playoffs. Then the owners decided they liked money and wanted more of it. The Wild Card round was added in 1994 but wasn’t used due to the labor stoppage. Starting in 1995, the playoff field for MLB doubled from four to eight and today, 12 teams will make the postseason. There have been different iterations of playoff formats since then and certainly more to follow as MLB leadership continues to tinker with the game to increase their bottom line.


201. Pirates take Roberto Clemente in Rule 5 draft (1954)

The 1954 Pirates stunk. They stunk every year of the 1950s before that too, but that’s not incredibly important here. By virtue of their 53-101 record in 1954, the Pirates were able to make the first pick in the Rule 5 draft that happened after the season and boy, did they make it count. Branch Rickey had been brought in to be the Pirates general manager in 1950 and the Buccos promptly finished dead last in the National League in four of the next five seasons. However, during that time, Rickey was sowing the seeds of what would eventually become the 1960 World Series championship team. He nabbed the crown jewel of that team in the 1954 Rule 5 draft when he snatched Roberto Clemente from the Dodgers AAA team, the Montreal Royals.

In his one season in the minor leagues, Clemente didn’t exactly set the world ablaze. He was much younger than the other players on the team at 19 years old, but only hit .257 with two home runs and 12 RBIs in 87 games. The Dodgers had the legendary Duke Snider in the outfield along with youngster Sandy Amoros, who had lit up the International League with the Royals just two short seasons before. They also had veteran All-Star Carl Furillo, so they didn’t anticipate a spot for Clemente anytime soon and left him unprotected. Rickey, whose separation from the Dodgers wasn’t exactly amicable, swiped him up. Rickey retired in 1955 due to health reasons, but by then, he had already secured Clemente, Bill Mazeroski, Dick Groat, Elroy Face and Vern Law for the Pirates and the rest, as they say, was baseball history.


Stay tuned for next week’s episode of The Stud 400 when we cross the halfway point in the countdown. That cause for celebration will bring out the biggest names in baseball history; literally 100 of them. We’ll also revisit an iconic All-Star Game dinger and take a trip around the bases, again, again, again and again. Be sure to come out and party with the stars in next week’s installment of The Stud 400.

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register