f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 6, 2026 8:59 am PDT

Whac-A-Mole

BY KEVIN KERNAN

And then there were four.

Three of them are super rich.

Such is the state of MLB in 2024, the rich do get richer. The NLCS starts Sunday night in LA with the magical Mets taking on the mighty Dodgers. The ALCS starts Monday in the Bronx with the Yankees facing the Guardians, a team they beat in the 2022 ALDS.

For bookkeeping purposes here are the payrolls of the four finalists:

The Mets are on top at $317 million. The Yankees are second at $309 million. The Dodgers, with the Shohei Ohtani discount, sit at $241 million. The Guardians are way down the list at No. 23 with a payroll of $106 million.

It needs to be said that Cleveland has not won a World Series since 1948. Back then they were called the Indians, and their logo was Chief Wahoo.

Gas was 26 cents a gallon the last time Cleveland won a World Series. The 1948 Best Picture winner was Hamlet. “To be or not to be, that is the question.’’

Unless something wacky happens, the Yankees will answer the question and will be back in the World Series for the first time since 2009, when they beat the Phillies for their 27th World Championship. As I said here at BallNine when this postseason started, the Yankees just need to win the AL Central to make it to the World Series, an E-ZPass trip.

Here is the one danger point for the Yankees. They only hit .220 against the Royals and .171 with runners in scoring position. That must improve.

The Yankees, like all the Final Four teams, must get ready to see a litany of relievers. That is what the Nerds have turned the postseason into these days.

“Who is pitching tonight?’’

“Who isn’t pitching tonight, we’ll see about eight of them.’’

Stephen Vogt #12 and Emmanuel Clase #48 of the Cleveland Guardians celebrate after defeating the Detroit Tigers in Game Five of the Division Series at Progressive Field on October 12, 2024 in Cleveland, Ohio. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Getty Images)

That is how many pitchers the Guardians used Sunday to beat the Tigers, 7-3 – and the Tigers can’t hit. The Tigers were not supposed to be in the postseason, but they do play in the AL Central, where anything is possible because teams can load up on wins against the White Sox. The Tigers hit only .214 against the Guardians and with runners in scoring position hit an embarrassing .109.

As much as they want to tell you batting average does not matter, it still matters. The Dodgers had the highest LCS batting average at .288, and get this, they hit .324 with RISP and .353 with two outs and RISP. The Padres hit .268 as a team but were shut out the final 26 innings, a lot of that against the Dodgers bullpen. Overall, the Padres hit .182 with RISP.

The party started a little too early in San Diego and Fernando Tatis & Co. paid the price.

Speaking of batting average, the Mets held the Phillis to a .186 mark in the NLDS and .194 with RISP. The Mets hit .269.

But, again, they say batting average does not matter until it matters.

And now we jump to a best-of-seven series, and those hitters will get plenty of looks at the teams who go bullpen crazy.

The way I look at the current trend of bringing in so many relievers that you lose count, it reminds me of a Saturday night down the New Jersey shore on the boardwalk, back in the day. At some point you are going to go into the arcade, after you had your two slices (pepperoni for me) and your Kohr’s Frozen Custard (Mrs. AMBS prefers a twist with chocolate syrup).

You got to work that food off, so you go play Whac-A-Mole.

Who doesn’t like to smash a mole, especially on a Saturday night?

The longer you play Whac-A-Mole the more you find a rhythm to smash moles. The same could be said for seeing a boatload of relievers. And now with it being a seven-game series the hitters should find more time to Whac-A-Reliever.

The game was invented in 1975 by TOGO, an amusements manufacturer in Japan. The longer you play Whac-A-Mole the more you find a rhythm to smash moles. The same could be said for seeing a boatload of relievers. And now with it being a seven-game series the hitters should find more time to Whac-A-Reliever.

You still need starting pitching to win, and you need at least two or three and a fourth is a bonus. A.J. Hinch and the Tigers found that out against the Guardians, although the Guardians braintrust took out their Saturday starter Matthew Boyd much too early after two innings and five strikeouts and were incredibly lucky that the Tigers just don’t have enough hitters. That is why the Guards had to go through those eight relievers to get past Detroit -and they do have a weapon in closer Emmanuel Clase, who has already pitched 5.2 innings this postseason.

Arizona lost the World Series last year because they were short of starting pitching. You can only trick ‘em for so long.

The stress, physical and mental, is tremendous on relievers.

“We’ll see the injury damage next year with these younger guys who are used to throwing two to three innings a week in the minor leagues,’’ a top evaluator told BallNine.

“You can’t pitch four or five guys every day, multiple innings for two weeks and have one starter during a playoff series,’’ he added of the Tarik Skubal or bust Tigers. In the three games that Skubal did not start the Tigers got a total of five innings from their starters. That is not going to cut it.

The Mets and Yankees – with ace Gerrit Cole – have been getting solid starting pitching.

“That’s why I think it is going to be a Subway Series,’’ the evaluator said of the Mets beating the Dodgers and the Yankees topping the Guardians. “At least the two New York teams have starters. I do not think the Dodgers, after what they had to do to get by San Diego are going to get by the Mets.’’

Cade Smith #36 and José Ramírez #11 of the Cleveland Guardians celebrate after defeating the Detroit Tigers in Game Five of the Division Series at Progressive Field on October 12, 2024 in Cleveland, Ohio. (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)

The Padres didn’t score the last 26 innings against the Dodgers. “It was embarrassing,’’ the evaluator said. “They changed their whole approach. The Padres chased so many bad pitches it was unbelievable. In a seven-game series you need three or four starters, unless you can sweep if the other team crumbles, but I don’t see the Mets crumbling.’’

The Dodgers starting pitching did okay against the Padres, accounting for 19.2 innings in the five games, but even in Game 5 the Dodgers had to rely heavily on their bullpen after Yoshinobu Yamamoto gave them five innings. Jack Flaherty, who gave the Dodgers 5.1 innings in his start against the Padres and allowed four runs, will get the Game 1 start against the Mets Sunday night at Dodger Stadium, and the Mets are countering with Kodai Senga, who can give the Mets three innings at most so it is the Mets who will be going with multiple relievers in Game 1 of the NLCS. Their ace Sean Manaea will start Game 2.

The Dodgers will need a lot more from their superstar Shohei Ohtani. Ohtani hit only .200 with one home run against the Padres but did have four RBIs. It was other bats like Teoscar Hernandez and Kiké Hernandez, both hit .333, batting average matters, who carried the Dodgers to victory.

“When you get late into those games, the Mets are a pretty special group,’’ the evaluator said.

They have turned it around with Francisco Lindor leading the way.

The Mets got a huge gift from the Phillies when Rob Thomson took out Zack Wheeler in Game 1 with a 1-0 lead after seven innings and the Mets came back to beat the bullpen and set the tone for the series.

Francisco Lindor #12 of the New York Mets celebrates with teammates after beating the Philadelphia Phillies 4-1 in Game Four of the Division Series at Citi Field on October 09, 2024 in Queens, New York. (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)

This certainly is not 1964 when the Cardinals’ Bob Gibson started three games in the World Series against the Yankees and pitched 27 innings in St. Louis’ seven-game series win.

Do yourself a favor this October and go read David Halberstam’s book October 1964 to get a feel for that brand of baseball – when starting pitchers ruled the day – if you want a glimpse of what baseball used to be and why it had such a hold on America. And for those who live for the pitch clock, consider this paragraph from Halberstam on Gibson.

“The Yankees would come to bat, barely have time to dig in, and the pitch would be on its way; then, just as they started to think about the next pitch, he was already in the windup.’’

This was 60 years ago, I was 11 years old, a Yankee fan, but also a baseball fan and mesmerized by Gibson’s intimidating greatness. To me, that is starting pitching in the postseason.

Can the Mets magic continue, or will this be a series loss to the Dodgers like the 1988 crusher when Mike Scioscia hit the home run that helped derail the Mets? I was covering that game, and I will never forget how stunned Shea Stadium became when the Doc Gooden pitch flew over the right-field fence from Scioscia’s blast. The catcher had hit only 35 career home runs, four a season. But that is playoff baseball. Anybody can be the hero. That is why we watch.

Meanwhile, the Yankees had bullpen questions during the year, but the postseason bullpen has been buoyed by the performance of new closer Luke Weaver. The Guardians don’t figure to put too much stress on the Yankee pitching staff and perhaps Aaron Judge will finally break out in the postseason. He came into the postseason batting .211 over his career and batted .154 against the Royals.

Luke Weaver #30 of the New York Yankees celebrates after a win over the Kansas City Royals in Game Four of the Division Series at Kauffman Stadium on October 10, 2024 in Kansas City, Missouri. (Photo by Ed Zurga/Getty Images)

I will say this, though, Royals scout Willie Fraser put together a great report on how to attack Judge. The Royals are a fine scout-based organization and made great strides this year. It was Giancarlo Stanton who stepped up in that series for the Yankees.

We’ll see how the Guardians approach it. The Yankees are going to have to deal with a strong Guardians bullpen, not only the closer, but the mid-game closer in Cade Smith, who has appeared in five postseason games and has struck out 12 over 6.1 innings. But managing a bullpen over a seven-game series is much different than a five-game series.

The big problem with the Guardians is the same problem I saw with the AL Central Royals.

Will the Guardians be able to score enough runs to beat the Yankees four times? Jose Ramirez and Josh Naylor both need to have big series. I loved the trade for Lane Thomas, an under the radar hitter, who blasted a grand slam in the 7-3 victory Saturday, and Steven Kwan, the leadoff hitter, will get on base. He batted .524 against the Tigers, but Ramirez struggled, batting .188 as did Naylor, who hit .200.

And don’t forget, the Yankees have that $200 million advantage.

45+ years, columnist at NY Post for the last 23 years prior to joining BallNine. Elected to the NY Baseball Hall of Fame. Former SportsTalk Host (KFMB), ESPN’s First Take and Cold Pizza contributor. Frequent guest on radio shows and podcasts nationwide. Author of seven books. Seen in episode 10 of ESPN’s “The Last Dance” (the one with Dennis Rodman). First baseball interview he conducted was with Thurman Munson. Now you know why he is America’s Most Beloved Sportswriter.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register