f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 9, 2026 1:35 pm PDT

The breaking of the color barrier in baseball is something that tends to get overly simplified. I’ll wager to say all baseball fans know that Jackie Robinson was the man who finally broke through as the first African American ballplayer in Major League Baseball. Most know that Larry Doby followed by integrating the American League just a few months later. You’ll probably also find a handful of baseball fans who know that Moses Fleetwood Walker was the last Black ballplayer to play in the Majors before Robinson. Very few probably know of Will White, a player whose mother was biracial. He played just one game in 1879 – and in 2004 it was discovered that his mother was half black, making White the first documented player with African American lineage.

What we’re getting at here is Major League Baseball’s color barrier was more of a moving target rather than a line in the sand. Take, for instance, the case of Charlie Tokohoma.

By all accounts, Tokohoma was an outstanding ballplayer who played at the turn of the 20th century. In fact, some opined he was one of the best of his era. He was a well-rounded second baseman, a deft baserunner and had the leadership acumen to be named team captain on one of his teams. He even led his 1896 squad to a championship. The reason he is a nearly unknown blip in baseball history is that Tokohoma only existed for a short period of time.

In actuality, Charlie Tokohoma was Charlie Grant, star second baseman for the Columbia Giants, a professional all-Black baseball team that predated the Negro Leagues. But briefly in 1901, Grant was on the cusp of becoming the first African American baseball player to break the understood color barrier of Major League Baseball thanks to a crafty plan by Hall of Fame manager John McGraw. Their story is one of the more fascinating tales of early baseball and slots in on this week’s Stud 400.

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

180: The Homer in the Gloamin’ (1938)

179: Go Crazy Folks: Ozzie Smith (1985)

178: This Week in Baseball Debuts (1977)

177: Jose Canseco joins 40-40 club (1988)

176: Ken Griffey Jr. and Sr. hit back-to-back home runs (1990)

And now, here’s Episode LIII of The Stud 400.

175. Pete Rose-Ray Fosse collision (1970)

With Pete Rose’s recent passing, some of his signature moments have found the spotlight again. Among the iconic plays that illustrated Rose’s competitive fire was his collision with Ray Fosse in the 1970 All-Star Game. It’s hard for today’s fan to comprehend that people used to play every single game, exhibition or not, with one goal in mind: to win. In 1970, the All-Star Game was a huge deal. No, it didn’t count for anything other than pride, but pride used to be enough for folks to play hard.

Rose represented the winning run in the 12th inning of the All-Star Game when Jim Hickman lined a shot to centerfield. The ball got to Amos Otis quickly on the Riverfront Stadium turf and the Gold Glove centerfielder came up throwing. It didn’t matter; Rose was a runaway train and Fosse was on the tracks. Rose got to Fosse a millisecond before the ball and blasted the catcher into oblivion. Rose buried his shoulder into Fosse’s left collarbone and the two players went tumbling over in a cloud of dirt. Rose got up quickly as the National League was victorious, but Fosse was left doubled over in pain on the field. Initial x-rays came back negative, and Fosse continued to play out the 1970 season, but it was eventually learned that Fosse did indeed fracture his collarbone and separate his shoulder in the play. Fosse won a Gold Glove in 1970 and finished 23rd in the MVP voting. He was an All-Star and Gold Glove winner again in 1971, but injuries lingered and his career never developed the way it was projected.


174. Smoky Joe Wood vs. Walter Johnson (1912)

Today’s fans will never comprehend how a great pitching matchup could be likened to a major heavyweight prizefight. Both have pretty much gone the way of the dodo. These matchups played more like heavyweight fights rather than baseball games and it went on for over 100 years – until the starting pitcher became persona non grata in today’s game.

Perhaps the first major publicized clash of stud pitchers of the sport came late in 1912 in a showdown at Fenway Park. On September 6, 1912, young upstart fireballer Smoky Joe Wood of the Sox faced off against the iconic Walter Johnson of the Senators, who was just 24 at the time. Despite his youth, Johnson was well-established as he was 111-88 with a 1.69 ERA for his career at that point. Wood was 22 years old and came into the game with a career record of 76-42 with a 1.95 ERA. Going into the game, Johnson was 29-10 on the season with a 1.53 ERA while Wood stood at 29-4 with a 1.88 ERA. Johnson had set a Major League record earlier in the season by winning 16 straight decisions and Wood was riding a 13-game winning streak into this game with thoughts that he could pass the record Johnson had just set. Senators manager Clark Griffith issued a challenge to the Red Sox that if Wood was to top Johnson’s record, he should have to go through the Big Train to do so. The Red Sox obliged and adjusted their rotation so that Wood and Johnson would face off.

The game itself lived up to the hype. Over 29,000 fans jammed into Fenway Park. Wood claimed that the Sox ran out of room in the stands, so fans were allowed to stand on the field and surrounded him as he was warming up. Wood and Johnson matched zeroes until the sixth when Tris Speaker laced a two-out double off Johnson. Duffy Lewis then lofted a flare down the right field line that fell just out of the reach of a diving Danny Moeller to give Wood and the Sox a 1-0 lead. That was all Smoky Joe needed. The Senators threatened in the eighth and ninth but couldn’t break through. In the eighth, Eddie Foster singled and stole second with one out, but Wood induced two pop-ups to end the threat. The last hope for the Senators came in the ninth when Frank LaPorte singled leading off and was bunted to second. Wood struck out the final two batters of the game though and came out victorious in what is sometimes called The War of 1912, one of the best regular season games of the Dead Ball Era.


173. John McGraw and Charlie Grant try to usurp the color barrier (1901)

OK, even by Stud 400 standards, this entry is bananas. By 1901, the color barrier in baseball had been well established as a “gentlemen’s agreement” even if it wasn’t in writing. No Black player had played in the Majors since Moses Fleetwood Walker in 1884, but that’s not to say there weren’t people in power looking to get around that. Light-skinned Latino players and Cubans who didn’t have African ancestry became some of the first non-white players in the Majors as did some Native Americans. Hall of Fame manager John McGraw, known as somebody who liked to bend the rules, was in his second year as player-manager of the Orioles and Charlie Grant was a barnstorming star and well-known Black player in the late 1890s. Where they first crossed paths is unclear, but apparently the two met in the early spring of 1901 to discuss a plan to bring Grant to the Orioles by telling the world he was a mysterious Native American star named Charlie Tokohoma, a Cherokee Indian from Oklahoma. One hurdle was that Grant was such a good player that Clark Griffith, Roger Bresnahan and other stars of the day knew exactly who he was. That didn’t stop McGraw from trying or even hiding the fact that he was trying to concoct this scheme.

Charlie Tokohoma was linked to the Orioles in articles in the Baltimore Sun and St. Louis Post-Dispatch and referred to as a “utility man signed by the impresario McGraw for his Baltimore American club.” The article mentioned that he might not only serve as a utility player, but also as a mascot doing “war-dance stunts.” His signing was pretty widely covered by newspapers of the time. It appears that Charlie Comiskey was the first person to blow the whistle on this, but Grant insisted that he was born to a Native American mother and white father. As opening day drew closer, McGraw eventually relented and did not include Grant on the Orioles roster, but that wasn’t the end of it. In May, McGraw was suspended five games for stomping on an umpire’s foot, getting ejected and then coming back later in the game to berate the umpire further. McGraw, who was also the team’s third basemen, ordered Grant to report to Boston where the Orioles were playing. McGraw’s plan was to sign Grant to replace him at third base during his suspension. This time, there was no effort to hide Grant’s identity. In fact, articles at the time casually mentioned Grant’s fleeting Native American identity as if it was no big deal. Ultimately, the whole plan was squashed, but it was quite possibly the closest any African American came to playing in the Majors between Fleetwood Walker and Jackie Robinson.


172. Shohei Ohtani breaks out (2021)

If you’re waiting around the countdown for Shohei’s 50-50 season, sorry it’s not happening. This isn’t some statement against the Ohtani Police—the sect of radical Ohtani rooters who deify him as an Asian Jesus—it’s just that this list was made after the 2021 season. Which means Ohtani’s historic 2021 breakout season got in just under the wire. Ohtani came to the United States billed as Japan’s Babe Ruth due to his unprecedented combination of hitting and pitching ability and he won the American League Rookie of the Year in his first season. He did well at the plate and was pretty good from the mound across 51 innings, but his debut season wasn’t exactly earth-shattering. Ohtani had offseason Tommy John Surgery, which kept him off the mound in 2019. He served as the Angels DH in 106 games in 2019 and just about mirrored his 2018 performance, but regressed at the plate in an injury-plagued 2020 season. Across his first three seasons, he played 254 games, batted .269 with 47 home runs and 147 RBIs with an OPS of .843. Solid, but not Ruthian. On the mound, he was 4-3 with a 4.39 ERA over 53.1 innings. He had 66 strikeouts while walking 30 batters. People were openly questioning whether Ohtani was going to approach the heights that some projected for him. In 2021, those people learned that they were quite wrong.

Finally healthy after two years of injury struggles, Ohtani broke through at the plate with a monster season. He belted 46 home runs, drove in 100 runs, scored 103 runs, batted .257 with an OPS of .965 and swiped 26 bases. The Angels increased his workload on the mound and he went 9-2 over 130.1 innings with a 3.18 ERA and 156 strikeouts. It was hard to process what we were seeing from Ohtani because, frankly, the last time anybody had a season that combined pitching and hitting to that level was 1919, Babe Ruth’s final season of extended mound work. Ohtani’s 2021 breakout season earned him his first MVP Award and a spot in the top half of The Stud 400 and he would only ascend from there.


171. Rogers Hornsby’s second Triple Crown (1925)

When it comes to rare feats in baseball, the batting Triple Crown is one of the toughest to pull off. It requires excellence in contact, power and run production and you have to do all three better than anyone else in the league. There’s a reason it’s only been done 15 times since 1900 and just once since 1967. Only two players accomplished the feat twice, Ted Williams and Rogers Hornsby and its Hornsby’s 1925 Triple Crown that lands him in this week’s Stud 400. He became the first person to have two Triple Crowns after he ripped through the National League in 1925 and it also capped what was arguably the best six-year run in baseball history. The main argument you’d get comes from Babe Ruth’s years from 1926-1930 and really that’s about it. Not Lou Gehrig, not Barry Bonds, not Ted Williams.

From 1920-1925, Hornsby’s 162-game average was .397 with 29 home runs, 137 runs scored, 249 hits and 133 RBIs. He won six straight batting titles, topping .400 in three of them. He also won six straight on base percentage titles, six straight slugging percentage titles and, obviously, six straight OPS titles. Not even Ruth did that during his historical stretch. Hornsby led the National League in total bases five of the six seasons in that span, only missing out on 1923 when he missed 50 games due to injuries. When Hornsby hit .424 in 1924, it was just the second time since the turn of the century that anyone topped the .420 mark—Nap Lajoie hit .426 in 1901—and nobody has hit higher than .406 since. Oh, and about those Triple Crowns. In 1922 he won the National League batting title by .047 points, the home run crown by 26 dingers and the RBI title by 20, so it wasn’t even close. In 1925, it was more of the same; nobody was even close to him in the National League and his totals in the Triple Crown categories led all of Major League Baseball. It was the perfect way to cap what was arguably the best six-year stretch of offensive baseball in MLB history.


Stay tuned for next week’s episode of The Stud 400 because we’ll still be in the Halloween mood. We’ll be administering last rites and putting some folks on the chopping block in a spooky edition of the countdown. We’re going streaking, doing some numerology and hanging with the Stars, so join us next week for a Stud 400 you don’t want to miss.

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register