f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 14, 2026 10:13 am PDT

Baseball, like all sports, is filled with plenty of “what if” cases. Guys who didn’t meet the expectations they set earlier in their careers for one reason or another.

It’s always a hot topic when brought up on social media and you’ll typically see the same responses. People wonder what would have happened if Doc and Darryl didn’t get wrapped up in drugs, if Bo Jackson didn’t injure his hip or if Jose Fernandez didn’t die in a boat accident.

All valid thoughts, indeed.

But this is The Stud 400 and we go deeper than the usual responses. We like to examine the big cases like those, but also the ones lost to time.

Like wondering what would happen if Smoky Joe Wood didn’t break his thumb, Big Ed Walsh’s arm stayed healthy or if Hall of Famer Addie Joss didn’t die at 30 just days before the start of the 1911 season.

Some of those are included at different points in The Stud 400, and some are not. What has prompted this discussion today though is that we’ve come to the point in the countdown where Pete Reiser makes an appearance. Not often talked about among the great “what if” cases in baseball history, Reiser was an incredibly dynamic player who made a huge impact in his first full season. He then lost his age 24-26 seasons to World War II, regained his MVP form after coming home but had his career cut tragically short due to his reckless style of play in the outfield.

How reckless was he? Reiser once crashed head-first so hard into the wall at Ebbets Field that he had to be administered Last Rites at the ballpark in case he didn’t make it. Reiser lived, but never regained his playing form after 1947. The immaculately talented ballplayer played for four teams over his final five partial seasons, exceeding 65 games played just once over that span.

The glimpse of Reiser’s career when healthy is so tantalizing, even though he is largely forgotten by this generation of fans. As a 22-year-old in his first full season, Reiser hit .343 and won the batting title. He led the National League in runs, doubles, triples, slugging and OPS while playing stellar defense. For remedial fans who don’t like to think beyond a single number, he led the National League with 8.0 WAR as well.

The Dodgers won the National League pennant in 1947 and Reiser finished second in the MVP voting as a young centerfielder that season. In fact, in the three seasons in which Reiser topped 120 games played, he was an All-Star and Top 10 MVP finisher in all three seasons.

Even if injuries got the best of Pete Reiser, we want to give him his rightful due in The Stud 400. Some people wrote songs or poems to nail down their place in the countdown. Reiser put himself inches from death by running into a concrete wall for his spot.

We love the toughness, so let’s get to this week’s installment.

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

175: Pete Rose-Ray Fosse collision (1970)

174: Smoky Joe Wood vs. Walter Johnson (1912)

173: John McGraw and Charlie Grant try to usurp the color barrier (1901)

172: Shohei Ohtani breaks out (2021)

171: Rogers Hornsby’s second Triple Crown (1925)

And now, here’s Episode LIV of The Stud 400.

170. Expos & Twins avoid contraction (2002)

On November 6, 2001, Major League Baseball owners voted 28-2 to contract the number of teams in the league by two. The only two teams who voted against the plan were the Expos and Twins because they were the ones most likely to get a death sentence, even though the A’s, Marlins and Rays weren’t necessarily safe either. Commissioner Bud Selig said at the time, “the teams to be contracted had a long record of failing to generate enough revenue to operate as a viable Major League franchise.”

A very simple explanation of the plight of the Expos and Twins was that their respective stadiums had become obsolete and unkempt, driving fans away and sapping revenue. The lack of financial resources prevented the teams from modernizing or replacing their stadiums and also affected the on-field product. The teams explored relocating, but nothing materialized there either.

It looked bleak for both franchises. However, the MLBPA filed a grievance a day after the vote to contract and a separate lawsuit in Minnesota saved the Twins. With other teams out of the running to be contracted, the only team left in danger was the Expos. It was finally decided that if baseball contracted by only one team, it would have made for an unbalanced schedule and preserving the 162-schedule would be a near impossibility. On January 12, 2002, talks about contraction ended and Major League Baseball announced that no teams would be contracted. The Twins obviously got a new ballpark and survived to this day. The Expos lived a little longer and their plight will come up later in The Stud 400.


169. Pete Rose 44-game hitting streak (1978)

When it comes to unbreakable records, Joe DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak is about as iron-clad as they come. A main part in that argument is that the closest streak to the record was 44 games, an absolutely incredible accomplishment, but still two weeks short of DiMaggio’s record. That 44-game streak came from Pete Rose. There have been six hitting streaks of 40 games in the history of baseball and Rose’s is the only one that happened after DiMaggio’s historic 1941 performance.

Rose hit safely in every game from June 14 through July 31. He had 18 multi-hit games during the streak and went 70-182 for a .385 average. His streak finally came to an end on August 1, 1978 when he went 0-4 in a 16-4 loss to the Braves. Rose walked leading off the game, lined out to the pitcher, grounded out to short, lined into a double play and then was struck out by Gene Garber to end the game. He fell short of DiMaggio but settled for the record of longest hitting streak in National League history. Since then, not many have come close to Rose. Paul Molitor reached 39 games in 1987, and Jimmy Rollins got to 38 in 2006. Luis Castillo and Chase Utley reached 35 games and Benito Santiago hit safely in 34 straight in 1987. Those are the only players to have come within 10 games of Rose’s 44 games in the 46 years since it happened.


168. Pete Reiser given last rites at Ebbets Field (1947)

Pete Reiser’s accomplishments were recounted in this week’s intro, so let’s focus on the incident that landed him in The Stud 400. Famed columnist Red Smith wrote about Reiser, “Pete may have been born to be the best player who ever lived, but there was never a park big enough to contain his effort. He was a man of immeasurable skill and unconquerable effort who played the only way he knew how…until he had literally broken his body to bits.” While playing ball in the Army during World War II, he crashed through an outfield fence and fell into a 10-foot ditch, separating his shoulder. But his signature injury was much worse. Yes, while some players have signature home runs or pitching performances, Reiser played with such reckless abandon that he has a “signature injury.” It likely cost him his stardom – and it came close to costing him his life.

On June 4, 1947, the Dodgers were playing the Pirates when Culley Rickard knocked a shot over Reiser’s head in centerfield. Reiser chased unrelentingly and ran head first into the unpadded wall in centerfield. Reiser crumpled at the base of the wall, bleeding profusely from his head, before he was carried from the field for immediate treatment. 20-year-old rookie Duke Snider replaced Reiser in centerfield; it was the future Hall of Famer’s 14th Major League game. Reiser was rushed into treatment for his injury with a very serious concern about bleeding in his brain, among other things.

Dick Young of the New York Daily News described the scene under Ebbets Field where Reiser was receiving treatment. He wrote, “As club physician Dominick Rossi made a nimble precursory examination of the bleeding skull, two priests were summoned. Through the partially open door, one priest could be observed in the foreboding administration of the Last Rites.” Reiser lived but was never the same player. Incredibly, and even though he was unconscious, he held onto the ball for the out.

Pete Reiser being carried off the field on a stretcher

Pete Reiser being carried off the field on a stretcher after suffering a concussion in 1942. (Photo via thisdayinbaseball.com)


167. 1971 MLB All Star Game (1971)

MLB All-Star Games used to be an iconic must-see event on the sports calendar. Like much of the sport, it just ain’t what it used to be anymore. There have only been seven All-Star Games viewed in less than 6.5 million homes – and they have all come over the last eight seasons. By comparison, the 1971 All-Star Game was viewed in 16.2 million homes. People just don’t care about it on the scale they once did.

About that 1971 All-Star Game though.

If you had to point to one game to show what the All-Star Game used to be, that ’71 game would be the best example. First, take a look at the sheer star power that was present. Twelve of the 16 position players who started the game ended up in the Hall of Fame. Altogether, 23 players from the game are Hall of Famers, both managers—Earl Weaver and Sparky Anderson–ended up in the Hall and even third base umpire Doug Harvey landed in Cooperstown. The lineups were so stacked that Roberto Clemente, Reggie Jackson, Pete Rose, Al Kaline and Harmon Killebrew were reserves! Inner-circle Hall of Famers like Willie Mays, Frank Robinson and Hank Aaron were in the twilight of their careers while other icons like Reggie Jackson, Tom Seaver, Juan Marichal, Johnny Bench and Rod Carew were some of the young superstars who were early in their careers. With all those legends on hand, if you figure the game would be great one, you were right.

The American League won 6-4 and every run came via the longball. Every home run hit was hit by a future Hall of Famer. Bench, Aaron and Clemente homered for the National League and Jackson, Killebrew and Robinson went deep for the AL. Many of the home runs were monumental as well. Jackson hit one off the light tower on the roof and Bench and Clemente blasted absolute bombs into the opposite field upper deck. Aaron’s homer was incredibly his first All-Star Game extra base hit. Robinson’s blast made him the first to homer in the All-Star Game for both leagues and Clemente’s homer came in what would be his final All-Star Game at bat. Every run scored and RBI in the game was delivered by a Hall of Famer as well. There were 12 total hits in the game and Bobby Murcer and Willie Davis were the only non-Hall of Famers to get a hit. The All-Star Game is meant to be a competitive showcase of the game’s greatest stars – and no Midsummer Classic embodied that more than the 1971 game.


166. Indians & Yankees add jersey numbers (1929)

Uniforms in baseball have always been in a constant state of change and some innovations are much better than others. Powder blues, pinstripes and stirrups were great in the grand scheme of uniform history. The 2024 Fanatics Temu-quality uniforms with ridiculous sponsor patches, not so much.

Possibly the greatest innovation in uniforms was adding numbers to the back of jerseys. The Cleveland Indians got the ball rolling on this, even if it was slow to take hold. In 1916, the Indians added numbers to the left sleeve of their jerseys for a trial period and used them in 1917 as well, but then abandoned them after that. History also shows that the Indianapolis ABC’s of the Negro National League and San Antonio Bears of the Texas League used sleeve numbers in 1923. Finally, in 1929, the Yankees and Indians both decided that they would wear large numbers on the backs of their jerseys. The Yankees season opener was rained out in 1929, making the Indians the first team in Major League Baseball to take the field with numbers on the backs of their jerseys. The numbers generally aligned with the players’ spots in the batting order, as the lineup rarely changed. So many baseball greats have come to be known by their numbers—42, 3, 21, 44, just to name a few—that it’s hard to think of a baseball world before time where numbers didn’t exist.


Stay tuned for next week’s episode of The Stud 400 when we break in with a pair of generational rookies and sit out with the rest of American society. We’ll cry when the wrecking ball comes for a cathedral and lie right to your face on an era-defining topic. On the Stud 400, all we do is talk about the past, so come on back next week as we barrel forward with the countdown.

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register