f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 8, 2026 6:57 am PDT

The Major League Baseball draft may not have the bells and whistles of the NFL Draft just yet, but they are trying their best to get there. That’s not to say the MLB Draft doesn’t have an interesting background, though.

Officially known as the Rule 4 Draft – and also referred to as the June draft or first-year player draft – it was instituted as an early means of preventing a situation where the richest teams like the Yankees and Cardinals were able to stockpile talent.

Prior to the draft, amateur players were simply able to sign with whatever teams they chose as free agents. The Cardinals were adept at hoarding young talent and were the first to build an expansive farm system to develop that talent; the poorer teams simply weren’t able to do that.

In 1947, MLB had their first attempt to control high-spending teams by instituting what was known as the bonus baby rule. If a team signed a player and gave him more than a $4,000 signing bonus, that player had to stay on the active Major League 25-man roster for two full seasons. Players like Harmon Killebrew, Sandy Koufax, Al Kaline and Roberto Clemente were bonus baby signees who went on to Cooperstown. The rule went through variations and was rescinded and reinstated but was generally effective.

Then the Yankees started to circumvent it.

The Yankees worked out a deal with the Athletics where they had the A’s sign Clete Boyer on their behalf. Boyer stayed on the A’s roster for the required two full seasons and just as he became eligible to be sent to the minors, he was traded to the Yankees. There were also rumors that teams were giving players smaller signing bonuses and then giving them secret payments in addition to their signing bonus. Ultimately, the Bonus Baby rule was seen as ineffective and scrapped.

The idea of a Major League Baseball Draft was voted on at the 1964 Winter Meetings and the Yankees, Mets, Cardinals and Dodgers attempted to rally other owners to vote against it. In the end, only the Cardinals ended up voting against it and a draft system was put in place.

The June draft was the largest draft and that consisted of recently graduated high school seniors and college seniors. The January draft involved high school players who graduated in the winter, junior college players and players who dropped out of four-year schools. There was also an August draft for players who played on amateur summer league teams.

The first MLB Draft was held in 1965 and Rick Monday was the first ever top overall pick. The next year the Mets drafted Steve Chilcott first overall and he became the first top pick to never make the Majors. That was duplicated by Brien Taylor decades later. Ken Griffey Jr. was the first top overall pick to make the Hall of Fame and he was later joined by Chipper Jones, Harold Baines and Joe Mauer.

There have been 60 drafts since its inception in 1965 and 23 top overall picks went on to become All Stars. Five of them won the Rookie of the Year Award. The Pirates have the most first overall picks with six followed by the Astros, Mets and Padres with five each. The Red Sox, Rockies, Reds, Dodgers, Giants, Cardinals and Blue Jays have never had the top pick in the draft.

A few events regarding the draft gained entry into The Stud 400 and this week we go right back to the beginning.

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

145: First televised MLB game (1939)

144: “Baseball’s Sad Lexicon” published (1910)

143: Lyman Bostock murdered (1978)

142: Luis Gonzalez beats Mariano Rivera (2001)

141: Umpires Bill Klem, Tom Connolly inducted into HOF (1953)

And now, here’s Episode LX of The Stud 400.

140. Rick Monday: First ever #1 Draft Pick (1965)

Greed and baseball have gone hand-in-hand since the dawn of time. Or at least the first time someone realized they could monetize the sport.

As rich teams hoarded players in the pre-draft and free agency eras, the divide between the haves and the have-nots was starting to become a huge chasm. The Yankees and Cardinals were the two financial powerhouses in baseball and won 13 of the 17 World Series played between 1931-1947, so baseball tried to find a system to promote parity within the sport. After other ideas failed, the teams voted to institute a first year player draft starting in June of 1965. Rick Monday led Arizona State to the NCAA title in 1965 and was the College Baseball Player of the Year. He later became the first ever #1 overall pick in the MLB Draft when the Kansas City A’s selected him.

While current lingo likes to call top overall picks “1-1,” Monday is the only person can say he was “1-1-1.” Along with Monday, future All-stars Joe Coleman, Ray Fosse and Jim Spencer were also first round picks. Other notable players taken in the inaugural draft were Johnny Bench (2nd round), Graig Nettles (4), Sal Bando (6), Nolan Ryan (12) and Tom Seaver, who was taken by the Dodgers in the 10th round, but then ended up somewhere else that I can’t recall at this point.


139. Yankees release Babe Ruth (1935)

About 700 years ago, Geoffrey Chaucer wrote that all good things must come to an end – and that saying was quite appropriate in the baseball world on February 27, 1935. That was the date that the tenure of the greatest ballplayer who ever lived came to an end on the game’s most recognizable franchise.

After four World Series wins and 659 home runs, Babe Ruth’s time with the Yankees was over. Ruth, who had just turned 40 three weeks earlier, wanted to hang on as a player and his goal of becoming a manager was gaining more traction, but it became clear that wasn’t going to happen in New York. By all accounts, it seemed like Ruth’s plan was to finish out his career in the Bronx and then take over for manager Joe McCarthy, who he had a lukewarm relationship with at best. Yankees owner Jacob Ruppert stood by McCarthy though, who would go on to manage the Yankees for 12 more seasons. Although well past his prime and out of shape, Ruth was still a credible drawing card and signed quickly with the Boston Braves, who had been a solid team but hadn’t been drawing well at the gate.

The deal not only locked in Ruth as a player, but it also gave him the role of Assistant Manager and second Vice President. It was also rumored that Ruth could take over as full-time manager in as little as two years and would share in team profits. Braves manager Bill McKechnie welcomed Babe, but made clear that he was the manager and he wasn’t planning on going anywhere. Ruth’s tenure with the Braves lasted all of 28 games before he retired for good after hitting .181 and the final six home runs of his career.


138. Pittsburgh drug trials (1985)

When it comes to black eyes for the sport of baseball, one question that seems fair to ask is, “Just how many eyes does baseball have?” One of the bigger scandals over the past 50 years is the Pittsburgh Drug Trials. While performance enhancing drugs like amphetamines were involved, much of the focus fell on the rampant cocaine use in Major League Baseball.

It was the ‘80s after all.

In September of 1985, a number of Pittsburgh Pirates and prominent players from other Major League teams were called to testify before a Pittsburgh grand jury and pulled back the curtain on drug use in baseball.

Keith Hernandez estimated that about 40% of all players used cocaine, including himself. John Milner talked about getting amphetamines from Willie Mays and Willie Stargell and even admitted to buying cocaine in a bathroom stall at Three Rivers Stadium during a game. Tim Raines admitted to keeping a gram of cocaine in his uniform pocket during games, he only slid head-first so he didn’t break the vial and that he snorted cocaine during games. Rod Scurry said that he had even left the stadium during games to go look for cocaine. Shit, even the mascots were in on the deal. Kevin Koch, the Pirate Parrot, was implicated in buying cocaine and connecting players with drug dealers.

In the end, 11 players were suspended, including Hernandez, Dave Parker, Dale Berra, Lonnie Smith and Jeffrey Leonard. All player suspensions were commuted under conditions that players perform community service, pay a fine and submit to drug testing. Ten other players were mentioned but not suspended including Dusty Baker, Vida Blue, Alan Wiggins and Gary Matthews. A number of other non-players served jail time for their role in the scandal.


137. The race to pass Walter Johnson (1984)

When Walter Johnson retired in 1927, he was the all-time strikeout leader with 3,509. Cy Young (2,803), Christy Mathewson (2,507), Rube Waddell (2,316) and Eddie Plank (2,246) rounded out the top five as it stood in 1927.

Johnson had blown away the career strikeout record by such a wide margin and had such a long and incredible career that it reasoned it would be a long time, if ever, that anyone would pass him. It eventually did happen, but it took nearly 60 years for the record to fall. The crazy thing about it is that Johnson went from having one of the most unbreakable records of all time to dropping down to fourth place in the span of about four months. This was the result of three incredible careers that all followed a similar trajectory to Cooperstown. Gaylord Perry made his MLB debut in 1962, Nolan Ryan made his in 1966 and Steve Carlton came onto the scene in 1965. They terrorized batters year after year and when the 1983 season started, all three were on the precipice of passing Johnson for the coveted record. Ryan was just 14 away, a number he could reach in his sleep. Perry started ’83 just 56 strikeouts behind Johnson and Carlton was 74 K’s away. As expected, Ryan was the first to pass Johnson when he struck out Expos pinch hitter Brad Mills. Carlton passed Johnson about three weeks later and Perry finally pulled ahead of The Big Train in August.

Ryan actually started the season on the disabled list and missed starts again after passing Johnson, which allowed Carlton to makeup some ground on Ryan’s total. Carlton was also in a four-man rotation and made 37 starts in 1983 compared to Ryan’s 29. All of that worked in Carlton’s favor and allowed him to pass Ryan. When the 1983 season ended, Carlton was the all-time strikeout leader with 3,709. Ryan was in second with 3,677 and Perry retired after the season in third place with 3,534. Ryan overtook Carlton for good in 1984 his total of 5,714 strikeouts is 839 K’s ahead of Randy Johnson, who is now in second place with 4,875. Walter Johnson has dropped down to ninth place and Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer are about 100 K’s each from passing him, if their elbows will allow. Aside from that, the only active players in the top 80 are Chris Sale (49) and Gerrit Cole (61), so none of us reading this are likely to ever see anyone approach Ryan, or even Johnson again for that matter.


Hippo Vaughn136. The double no-hitter (1917)

When you think about the greatest game ever pitched, some real doozies probably come to mind.

We already discussed the historic matchup between Walter Johnson and Smoky Joe Wood on The Stud 400. That game came in at #174. Juan Marichal and Warren Spahn hooked up for a classic in 1963 when Marichal threw 227 pitches and Spahn 201 with each pitcher carrying a shutout in the 16th inning! You could certainly make the case for the Dodgers vs. Cubs game on September 9, 1965. In that game, Bob Hendley allowed just one hit over eight innings and lost because the fellow on the other side, Sandy Koufax, happened to throw a perfect game. Of the 53 batters those pitchers faced, they allowed just one hit and one walk. It remains the only nine-inning game in which the teams combined for just one hit. How do you beat that? Let me introduce you to Fred Toney, Hippo Vaughn and the double no-hitter.

On May 2, 1917, Vaughn took the mound for the Cubs as they hosted the Reds for an early season showdown at Weegham Park, which is what Wrigley Field was named before it was Wrigley Field. Vaughn and Toney traded zeroes and about an hour and a half after the game started, the ninth inning rolled around with no runs or hits by either team. Vaughn ripped through a perfect ninth inning and when the Cubs came up in the bottom of the frame, all they needed to do was push across a run to nail down the win and no-hitter. But as he did the previous eight innings, Toney matched Vaughn and set the Cubs down in order, so the game went to the 10th with neither team getting a hit through nine innings. That hasn’t happened before or since.

In the top of the 10th, the Reds’ Larry Kopf finally got to Vaughn when he stroked a clean one-out single to right. Hal Chase reached on an error by Cubs star Cy Williams and stole second to put runners at second and third with two outs. Jim Thorpe (yes that Jim Thorpe!) then hit a little nubber in front of home plate and beat the throw to first, allowing Kopf to score the game’s first run. Toney then set the Cubs down in order in the bottom of the 10th to seal the win and no-hitter.

Whether you want to call it the greatest game ever pitched may be up for debate, but what isn’t up for debate is that there is only one game ever that is referred to as the double no-hitter and it comes in at #136 on The Stud 400.


Stay tuned for next week’s episode of The Stud 400 when we look at some extreme highs and lows of the game’s history. We’re celebrating Father’s Day with a Hall of Famer and reliving one of the great World Series performances of all-time. Unfortunately, we’re also diving into another black eye for baseball and remembering a fantastic baseball man who we could use around the game these days for sure. Be there next week when we turn on the lights for an all-new installment of The Stud 400.

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register