f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 8, 2026 9:21 pm PDT

Twin Killing

BY KEVIN KERNAN

The Twins are for sale, and that’s a really good thing for Twins fans to finally rid themselves of the Pohlad family.

Beware, though. A sale is not going to cure all the Twins’ ills because the Twins are being run by an overly analytical front office that is clearly not in touch with the fans.

That is what we are seeing and the word we are getting here at BallNine from numerous sources familiar with how the Twins operate under president of baseball operations Derek Falvey and his right-hand man – someone you probably have never heard of named Josh Kalk, who holds the title VP Baseball Operations Strategy and Innovation.

In November Falvey was also promoted to president of business operations so he is in charge of all phases of Twins baseball.

All that “strategy and innovation’’’ led the Twins to a collapse this past season and a fourth-place finish in the meek AL Central.

You could call it a Twin Killing.

In three of the last four seasons the Twins have finished 20 games out, 14 games out and 10.5 games behind in the AL Central.

Through the years the Twins have had an easy road in that division, but other AL Central teams are beginning to improve, so the Twins are finally facing a bit more competition.

Make no mistake, this is not exactly the AL East, and the Twins are no longer the strong scouting based, people-first organization that they were in the days of Terry Ryan and Mike Radcliffe, a legendary scout, who passed away in 2023.

A lot has changed.

More cubicles mean more analysts, fewer baseball boots on the ground.

“They really are kind of a mess,’’ one evaluator told BallNine this week. “They are very arrogant. And if you are paying attention, you can see that they are going deeper and deeper into analytics and it’s not working.

“The Twins are getting away from true scouting and Falvey is just adding more and more cubicles.’’

More cubicles mean more analysts, fewer baseball boots on the ground.

That is never a good thing no matter how teams try to spin it, this is still a game where you need savvy baseball people making decisions, witness Dave Roberts’ success in the World Series with the Dodgers against the Yankees.

The Twins new ownership group is going to have to take a hard look at how the Twins do business under Derek Falvey, who has led the baseball operations for eight years. Falvey has all the power … at least until the new owner arrives – and that could happen before Opening Day.

The Twins completely collapsed down the stretch in 2024, losing 18 of their final 24 games. They have not appeared in the AL Championship Series since 2002 and have not won a World Series in 33 years. In 2023 they finally ended a humiliating 18-game postseason losing streak, beating the Blue Jays in the Wild Card Series before getting quickly bounced by the Astros in the ALDS.

Last October, they sat it out.

Call me extra critical but occasionally winning a division title in a weak division only to get embarrassed in the postseason is not my definition of success, and it is easy to blame the owners; but there are a lot of bad owners in baseball and the Pohlads did spend money to sign Carlos Correa, some $350 million. They signed Byron Buxton to a huge extension and Falvey gave Pablo Lopez $73.5 million.

Minnesota Twins chief baseball officer Derek Falvey prior to the game against the Kansas City Royals on April 3, 2017 at Target Field in Minneapolis, Minnesota. (Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/Getty Images)

Now, ownership did order the front office to slash $30 million after their first playoff series win in two decades following the 2023 season because of TV troubles and wanting to put more cash in their pockets before they sell the team. There is no getting around that, so a change in ownership is welcome by all Twins fans – but it is also a convenient excuse to tolerate mistakes made by the current front office.

Part of the beauty of being around baseball as long as I have is you get to know so many wonderful people who know the game inside-out. A number of those people are appalled by what is happening in the Twins front office and how out of touch they have become in the real baseball world.

As I said, much of their scouting is now based on video and numbers, what remains of the pro scouting department is just trying to survive, same for the amateur scouts. More of the human touch is needed.

“A lot of people were let go to save money and Falvey just kept building cubicle after cubicle for analysts. He became more and more of a mad scientist, Dr. Frankenstat,’’ the evaluator explained. “They are down to like five pro scouts and those guys are all doing video.”

And you know what? Some of the other teams in the weak division are finally getting better so there is a bit more competition in the AL Central. If the Tigers and Royals really get their act together, the Twins will be in serious trouble and could easily finish fourth again in 2025. Cleveland had been their only competition in recent years. It promises to be a year of walking on eggshells anyway in Twins Land. Whenever a new owner comes into the picture to view how a team is run and who that owner eventually puts his trust in to run the show is always a fascinating experience.

Tighten your seat belts.

Executive chair Joe Pohlad of the Minnesota Twins looks on during a team workout on February 20, 2024 at the Lee County Sports Complex in Fort Myers, Florida. (Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/Getty Images)

I’ve known legendary Minnesota columnist and radio personality Patrick Reusse for decades and he is a word wizard. He recently named Joe Pohlad as his Turkey of the Year, writing, “Joe seems like the right Pohlad to follow his late grandfather Carl, the only two-time winner of the prize, as Turkey of the Year before the family sells the club,’’ Reusse wrote.

And Turkey of the Year covers all sports in Minnesota – not just baseball.

In the same column Reusse awarded Derek Falvey his P.J. Fleck Gibberish Award for “his triple-speak in trying to explain the departure of General Manager Thad Levine,’’ Reusse wrote, before adding this little zinger. “Unsaid: Thad’s contract ran out and the Twins didn’t renew it.’’

Twins fans don’t believe in the Twins right now, that’s for sure. The Vikings own the town, heading into Wild Card Weekend. The Twins, despite playing in one of the most beautiful ballparks in the Major Leagues, drew only 1.9 million fans in 2024, and haven’t been over the 2 million mark since 2019.

Target Field is one of my favorite ballparks all around, a great place to watch a ballgame.

The Twins’ playoff failures have been well documented. They have been the personal punching bag of the Yankees for decades and I saw that in person many times. The Twins last won the World Series in 1991, and AMBS was there to see that World Series under a much different Twins leadership group back when well respected baseball man Terry Ryan was the scouting director. Ryan would soon become GM.

The Twins have brought back some of their former players to take on special assistant roles, top notch people like Michael Cuddyer and LaTroy Hawkins, but who knows if those players actually have any actual input into any real decisions made by this front office. Again, Falvey relies heavily on the opinion of Josh Kalk, who has spent seven years with the club after originally joining the team as Senior Analyst of Baseball Research and Development.

The GM is Jeremy Zoll. He had been the assistant GM.

Twins new GM Jeremy Zoll (photo by Aaron Lavinsky /The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Kalk has a unique role because he is in the clubhouse talking to coaches about strategy and dealing with manager Rocco Baldelli. Baldelli is a solid person and it would be a plus if he had more input and not have to always follow a front office script.

That is what I call “front office coaching’’ and that is always an interesting dynamic. Remember when Twins pitching coach Wes Johnson suddenly left the team to become pitching coach at LSU? Front office coaching might have had something to do with it.

Kalk originally worked for the Rays and graduated from Michigan State with a Master of Science degree in Physics and owns a Bachelor of Science degree in Physics and Mathematics from the University of Wisconsin-River Falls.

The Twins have made some poor trades recently, including giving up prospects Spencer Steer, Christian Encarnacion-Strand and Steven Hajjar to the Reds for pitcher Tyler Mahle. The Reds also acquired right-handed pitcher, a top prospect, Chase Petty, 21, in the deal for Sonny Gray. Then there was the Jorge Lopez trade with the Orioles, losing reliever Yennier Cano, who became an All-Star and pitching prospect Cade Povich. Acquiring Sam Dyson didn’t work out. Then there was the deal where they traded Jose Berrios to Toronto for Austin Martin and Simeon Woods Richardson. They also traded away local product Nick Anderson way back in 2018 to the Marlins for Brian Schales. Anderson was soon traded to the Rays, where he struck gold.

The front office needs to find a way to better connect with their fans and that means finding players who connect with the fans. Winning helps – but even when they last won the division in 2023 the Twins were outdrawn by the Reds. The Twins won the division with 87 wins, not a great number, and drew 1,974,124 fans to Target Field. For comparison, the Reds, who won 82 games and finished third in the NL Central in their Great American Ball Park that does not come close to measuring up to Target Field, drew 2,038,302 fans.

Then there are the Rockies, who lost 101 and 103 games each of the last two seasons but drew 2.5 million fans last season and 2.6 million fans in 2023.

The Twins must do better.

The clock is running on Falvey, who comes from the East Coast, and has had eight years to win over the Minnesota fans. New ownership may spark a revival, but it always comes back to the product on the field, and this leadership group must find a way to connect with the upper midwest Twins fan base.

New owners will demand the Twins be relevant again.

45+ years, columnist at NY Post for the last 23 years prior to joining BallNine. Elected to the NY Baseball Hall of Fame. Former SportsTalk Host (KFMB), ESPN’s First Take and Cold Pizza contributor. Frequent guest on radio shows and podcasts nationwide. Author of seven books. Seen in episode 10 of ESPN’s “The Last Dance” (the one with Dennis Rodman). First baseball interview he conducted was with Thurman Munson. Now you know why he is America’s Most Beloved Sportswriter.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register