f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 11, 2026 2:38 pm PDT

When you mention “Murderer’s Row” to baseball fans, they’ll immediately associate the term with the New York Yankees. They’ll likely know that Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig were part of the team associated with that phrase, but that’s about it.

In the baseball parlance of today, Murderer’s Row has come to represent the 1927 Yankees, specifically the first six batters in that lineup. Those batters were Earle Combs, Mark Koenig, Ruth, Gehrig, Bob Meusel and Tony Lazzeri. All but Meusel and Koenig are enshrined in Cooperstown.

When you dig a little deeper though, the term wasn’t exclusive to the 1927 Yankees or even to the sport of baseball in general. There is some controversy surrounding both the origin of the phrase and when it came into baseball’s lexicon.

There’s a fantastic breakdown by John Thorn and you can find it here.

But here’s the short of it:

There are two main theories about where the term “murderer’s row” came from. The earliest reference came in an 1899 book titled Nooks and Corners of Old New York and it talks about a place called Otter’s Alley, which ran east to west connecting Sullivan and Thompson Streets in New York City. The alley has been proven to predate the Civil War all the way back to 1827, but there is no date as to when the alley, littered with vagrants, lawlessness and general repugnance first gained that moniker.

Jumping forward in history, we do know that The Tombs, the colloquial name of the Manhattan Detention Complex, had a row of cells reserved for the most hideous criminals that was dubbed Murderer’s Row. The Tombs opened in 1838 and the earliest mention of Murderer’s Row at the prison came in an article in The New York Herald on November 22, 1852. The article mentioned specifically that cells numbered 39-45 were called Murderer’s Row and the author of the article mentioned visiting “the wretched men confined in them.”

Charles Dickens even toured The Tombs and described it thusly. “Such indecent and disgusting dungeons as these cells, would bring disgrace upon the most despotic empire in the world.”

Yikes.

So there is a timeline issue there. Murderer’s Row (Otter’s Alley) predates the mention about the The Tombs by at least 25 years, but nobody seems to know when Otter’s Alley was first called Murderer’s Row. It’s possible that section of cells in The Tombs derived the name from Otter’s Alley or it could have been the other way around.

Surely in the baseball history books, things are much clearer, right? Nope.

The term Murderer’s Row was actually associated with several different baseball teams prior to the 1927 Yankees. The 1905 Cleveland Naps, which featured Hall of Famers Nap Lajoie and Elmer Flick, were perhaps the first lineup to be called “Murderer’s Row.” A headline in a 1912 print of the Wilkes-Barre Times-Leader called the 1912 Phillies “Murderer’s Row” as well. Incidentally, both the 1905 Naps and 1912 Phillies stunk. In 1914, Boston Braves pitcher Dick Rudolph recounted having to face the Philadelphia A’s. In an article after a game, he said, “I felt a little timid as I faced the first batter of “Murderer’s Row,” which was Eddie Collins.

Even within Yankees history, the term was used to describe the lineup even before Ruth and Gehrig were in pinstripes. It was first used to describe the 1918 Yankees. Lou Gehrig was 15 years old and Babe Ruth was in his fourth full season as a Red Sox pitcher at the time.

The term seemed interchangeable as some minor league and college teams even gained the nickname. However, once the 1927 Yankees bashed their way through the American League as the latest iteration of Murderer’s Row, the term became most associated with that squad, and rightly so.

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

115: Joe Nuxhall makes MLB debut (1944)

114: Jackie Robinson steals home (1955)

113: Tony Conigliaro beaning (1967)

112: David Cone perfect game (1999)

111: Mickey Lolich tops Bob Gibson in Game 7 (1968)

And now, here’s Episode LXVI of The Stud 400.

110. First MLB All-Star Game (1934)

The Major League Baseball All-Star Game still remains the best among all sports, even if it doesn’t have the luster and competitive nature that it used to.

The first MLB All-Star Game was actually part of the 1933 World’s Fair and was initiated by Arch Ward, who was the sports editor of the Chicago Tribune at the time. It was intended to be a one-off event, but the popularity of the game coerced Major League Baseball to make it an annual event. Right from the start, the All-Star rosters were chosen by fans and managers. The game itself featured so many of the game’s immortals. Of course, Babe Ruth was the headliner, even though he was 39 and in the final full season of his career. Ruth gave the fans a thrill when he fittingly cracked the first All-Star Game home run in the third inning. Interestingly, the first All-Star Game run was driven in by the least likely source in the lineup: starting pitcher Lefty Gomez, whose single drove home White Sox third baseman Jimmy Dykes in the second inning.

The game featured 19 future Hall of Famers including Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx, Carl Hubbell, Al Simmons and Charlie Gehringer among others. The teams were also managed by future Hall of Famers Connie Mack and John McGraw. Frankie Frisch his the first homer for the National League, a solo shot off General Crowder in the sixth. Lefty Grove pitched the final three innings for the American League to pick up the save in a 4-2 win for the junior circuit.


109. Murderer’s Row Yankees win World Series (1927)

With apologies to the Whiz Kids and Gashouse Gang, no nickname fits a team better than the 1927 Murderer’s Row Yankees.

The team featured the greatest player of all-time in Babe Ruth, a 24-year-old Lou Gehrig who was just reaching his peak, Hall of Fame center fielder Earle Combs who hit .356 with an insane 23 triples and Tony Lazzeri, a fourth Hall of Fame position player. The rotation was anchored by Waite Hoyt and Herb Pennock, two more Hall of Famers and the entirety of the brain trust—manager Miller Huggins, owner Jacob Ruppert and team president Ed Barrow have all been enshrined in Cooperstown as well. Just as the ’27 Yanks bludgeoned teams on the diamond, the best way to quantify this team is by beating you over the head with their statistics. Ruth cracked an incomprehensible 60 home runs while driving in 165 and hitting .356. His OPS was a preposterous 1.258. Gehrig wasn’t far behind. He hit 47 homers, 52 doubles and even added 18 triples. Gehrig hit .373 with a 1.240 OPS and led the team with 173 RBIs, a record at the time.

From a team perspective, the Yankees hit 158 home runs, which was over 100 more than the Philadelphia A’s, who finished second with 56. Their run differential was +371. By comparison, last year the Dodgers led Major League Baseball with a +156 mark. The only modern teams to crack a +300 run differential were the 2022 Dodgers (+334), 1998 Yankees (+309) and the 2001 Mariners (+300). How did this all translate in the standings? Incredibly well, as you’d expect. The Yankees went 110-44-1 and then swept the Pirates in the World Series. If you count their World Series sweep, their .721 winning percentage ranks as the best all time. They were in first place from the first game of the season and won the American League by 19 games. The last place Red Sox were buried by a 59-game deficit. No matter how you slice it, the 1927 Yankees absolutely murdered their competition and the nickname that sticks with them a century later was most certainly well-earned.


108. Joe Sewell strikes out (1925)

Technically, this entry in The Stud 400 is four separate entries rolled into one. The title of the entry is entirely accurate though, simple as it may seem: Joe Sewell strikes out. It’s not that he struck out with the World Series on the line or anything. It’s just, “Joe Sewell struck out.” If you’re asking why that’s any kind of big deal, well, let me introduce you to Joe Sewell. You see, Sewell was perhaps the toughest man to strike out in baseball history. Over the course of his career, Sewell struck out at a rate of one strikeout per 61 at bats. The only player who had a better rate was Willie Keeler, whose career started in 1892 when the mound was still just 45 feet.

The whole point about this being four entries in one is because Sewell struck out four times in 1925. Read that again. Four times all season. It’s not like this is some kind of trick entry either. Sewell had 699 plate appearances in 1925 and struck out at a rate of one strikeout per 152 at bats. He struck out looking in the Indians fourth game of the season and then struck out again in game 16. Sewell struck out looking again on May 30 against star pitcher Dutch Leonard and then over the course of the final 117 games of the season, Sewell struck out just once more. This time, Bob Shawkey of the Yankees got him. Shawkey was third in the American League in strikeouts per nine innings in 1925 behind immortals Lefty Grove and Walter Johnson. What makes Sewell’s contact rate even more impressive is that he wasn’t just some slap hitter looking to bunt and play small ball. Throughout the 1925 season, he frequently served as the Indians cleanup hitter. He also batted fifth, a run-producing spot, a number of times. Sewell wasn’t any kind of home run hitter, but he was a doubles hitter. He was in the top ten in the American League for two-baggers seven times over 13 full seasons, including 1924 when he led the league with 45 doubles. Sewell drove home over 100 runs twice and topped 80 RBIs in five other seasons. But contact is how Sewell made his name. From 1925 through the end of his career in 1933, he never struck out more than 10 times. Twice he struck out just three times in a season—1930 in 414 plate appearances and 1932 in 125 plate appearances. We chose the 1925 season for this entry because it was the season in which he had his most times to the plate (699) and still managed to maintain his insane contact rate.


107. Mickey Mantle’s Triple Crown (1956)

By 1955, Mantle was already one of the game’s great young superstars.

At 24 years old, he was a hero to Yankee fans and already carving out a place for himself following Joe DiMaggio as the next Yankee legend. Then in 1956, he took things to another level and turned in what would be his signature season at the age of 25. Mantle not only won the American League Triple Crown, but he led the Majors in all three Triple Crown categories—52 home runs, 130 RBIs and a .353 batting average.

It was just one of six times that a player won a Major League Triple Crown. In addition, he led the Majors in runs scored, total bases, slugging, OPS, extra base hits and just about any nerd stat you could shake a stick at. Since Mantle’s Triple Crown, only Frank Robinson (1966), Carl Yastrzemski (1967) and Miguel Cabrera (2012) have turned the trick. Mantle’s 52 home runs was the most in any of the 17 Triple Crown seasons. Mantle capped the season by belting three home runs in the World Series as the Yankees captured crown number 17. Mantle nabbed his first of three MVP Awards, winning unanimously over teammate Yogi Berra. It was just the third unanimous MVP in the American League at the time.


106. Ty Cobb’s 3,000th hit (1921)

We get that the game of baseball has always been fundamentally the same sport since the late 1800s, but the way that the game was played at the turn of the 20th century is entirely different than the way it’s played today. Even so, that doesn’t make any of Ty Cobb’s feats less spectacular.

By the time Cobb was 28 years old, he already captured nine batting titles and led the American League in hits six times. The black ink on Cobb’s early career is downright preposterous. Cobb never really slowed down, even batting .357 in 133 games as a 40-year-old in 1927. The longevity of his peak is pretty much unmatched in the sport. On August 19, 1921, Cobb became the youngest player to reach 3,000 hits, doing so at the age of 34. He was the youngest to 1,000 and 2,000 hits too. The only problem with Cobb’s 3,000th hit is that while the date is accurate, nobody is quite sure which hit was number 3,000 due to discrepancies in research that have been found over the years. Cobb went into game two of the doubleheader needing anywhere from 1-3 hits depending on whose research you believe, but since he got three hits in the game, he ended the day with between 3,000-3,002 hits. Cobb was the fourth Major League to reach 3,000 hits with only Cap Anson, Honus Wagner and Nap Lajoie doing so before him.


Stay tuned for next week’s episode of The Stud 400 when we reach the end for two icons of the game. We’re also going all the way back to crown the very first champion and seeing what happens when somebody abandons their signature pitch in the most historic game of their career. We’re coming up a little short in next week’s Stud 400 but we’ll also counter that with an appearance by The Tall Tactician, so be sure to join us next week at BallNine.

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register