f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 17, 2026 6:47 pm PDT

After the Honeymoon

BY KEVIN KERNAN

Welcome to New York Juan Soto. You have officially arrived.

Last year with the Yankees was your honeymoon. This is the real New York – the one that shows no mercy to a struggling superstar. It comes with the territory.

Yes, a mind boggling 15-year contract worth $765 million changes the perspective of fans and players now that Soto is a Met. Last year Aaron Judge and Soto were Batman & Robin. This year Soto is expected to be Superman, every game. That is just the way it is, and the sooner Soto comes to that realization the better off he will be as a Met.

At BallNine we are here to help. There are a number of things wrong with his swing right now, and that is why he is off to a bad start in his Mets Forever career.

This March/April Soto is hitting .231 and owns a .798 OPS. Last March/April in Pinstripes, Soto batted .325 with a 1.019 OPS. Soto was 0-for-5 inn the Mets, 4-3, 10-inning loss to the Twins Wednesday at Target Field, including hitting into an unassisted double play to the second baseman with the bases loaded to end the top of the fifth. He also struck out three times.

The first thing Soto has to do is chill out and start acting like Juan Soto again. Yes, as he explained earlier this week, teams are pitching him differently and that’s because he doesn’t have the Hulk behind him in the batting order, Aaron Judge.

Of course, teams are pitching him differently.

Wouldn’t you?

And by Soto stating that fact it is not a slap in the face to Pete Alonso, who is off to a wonderful start. It is merely baseball reality.

And by Soto stating that fact it is not a slap in the face to Pete Alonso, who is off to a wonderful start. It is merely baseball reality. You knew Yankee fans were going to jump all over the slightest sign of failure for Soto because the Yankees came in second place in the Soto Sweepstakes, offering $760 million for 16 years.

Ben Rice is enjoying the experience of hitting in front of Judge and is making the most of the opportunity. Cody Bellinger, hitting .180, batted in front of Judge Wednesday night against the Royals.

All this is the real New York, Juan.

Mets fans will probably give Soto a warm welcome come Thursday night at Citi Field, at least they should, and he needs to focus on that. Soto also needs to do what he does best in the batter’s box and that again is to chill out and be Juan Soto.

I am not seeing the free and easy Soto in the box so far this season, the Soto who rhythmically approaches every at-bat like a baseball dance. That tells me he is thinking too much up there. He is not himself. He is not taking the fun approach to the game that is his calling card. His movements are much too quick. He is trying to force the action. Everything is moving too fast right now in Juan Soto’s world.

Juan Soto #22 of the New York Mets during an at-bat at Target Field on April 16, 2025 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The Twins defeated the Mets 4-3 in ten innings. (Photo by David Berding/Getty Images)

That is the adjustment he needs to make now that Judge is not there to protect him in the lineup. Judge does much more than that for all the Yankees. He is the perfect clubhouse leader and that was where he was a big help to Soto as well. Everything Yankee related fell on Judge’s shoulders and he deftly handled it all.

The Mets don’t have that player and as a whole, I believe, the team made a mistake in simply handing the leadership keys to Soto because of the incredible contract. Soto is human and needed to go with the flow. It would help if Francisco Lindor, the closest thing the Mets have to Judge, takes that role head on now. And that doesn’t happen by just saying, “That mistake is on me.’’

The beauty of Judge, and I said this from the first time I met him and was the first writer to write about him in depth, is that Judge always talks team. He does not get carried into squabbles and even deftly avoided controversy after Soto made his honest baseball comments this week that teams are pitching him differently than last year. When Soto said to Mike Puma: “It’s definitely different. I had the best hitter in baseball (Judge) hitting behind me last season. I was getting more attacked and more pitches in the strike zone. I was pitched different last year.’’

All true.

That is pure baseball talk. Pitchers went after Soto. All this is not a slam on Pete Alonso. Judge is the most feared hitter in baseball. Pitchers took their chances with Soto and you know what, it worked out for both Soto and Judge. Soto was geared to hit last year and was ready for the fastball.

This year he is getting more breaking balls and needs to be geared up for that and make that adjustment. Here is something else that no one has mentioned.

The Yankees have one of the best assistant hitting coaches in the game in veteran coach Pat Roessler. Roessler and Soto have a strong relationship dating back to their days together in Washington.

I noticed last year that whenever Soto was in the dugout after an at-bat, a good or bad at-bat, Soto would eventually make his way to Roessler and the two would talk over the at-bat. On the good ones, it was positive reinforcement. On the bad ones it was about getting back on track.

Roessler is still with the Yankees, so Soto does not have the long-time hitting relationship to lean on this year with the Mets. That is not a slight on the Mets’ hitting coaches, that is just a fact. It will take Soto time to build that new relationship.

All that is part of the equation and is another reason why Soto needs to chill now more than ever and let the at-bat come to him. His movements in the box have been much too quick. There is not that showing of extreme confidence. Not yet.

The irony of all this is that Judge last March/April was the one who struggled, batting only .207 with a .754 OPS.

Aaron Judge #99 and Juan Soto #22 of the New York Yankees during Game Five of the 2024 World Series at Yankee Stadium on October 30, 2024 in New York City. The Dodgers defeated the Yankees 7-6. (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

Judge, as is his style, refused to get drawn into the Soto 2025 Experience, saying essentially Alonso offers great protection for Soto and that Soto “just needs to keep being himself. He’s going to be just fine.’’

Judge had no interest in getting in a back and forth with the media concerning Soto. That’s what Yankee Captains do. He’s not about to be the straw that stirs the drink as Reggie Jackson once did.

The Mets are struggling to score runs and as a team are hitting only .219, 21st in the majors, so Soto is not alone. The Dodgers as a superteam are hitting only .234 but are tied with the Yankees going into Wednesday night, each team with 32 home runs. The Mets are 21st in home runs with only 15. The Braves are hitting hard times too and are batting only .222 as a team and amazingly struck out 19 times in a 3-1 loss to the Blue Jays on Wednesday. The Braves’ top three hitters somehow managed to strike out 11 times. Leadoff hitter Michael Harris II struck out four times as did No. 2 hitter Austin Riley while No. 3 hitter Matt Olson K’d three times. Harris II is batting .178 and Olson is hitting .203.

There is a lot of pathetic hitting going on in baseball right now because of what is being taught to hitters from analysts and not true baseball people. Those metric readers insist strikeouts and batting average don’t matter. They do matter and that continues to be the Big Lie of the Analytics Generation.

Soto is so successful because he is an old school hitter, hitting the ball where it is pitched, but he is not doing that now – and on the fifth inning double play he rolled over the pitch just like any average hitter would – and that is not Juan Soto.

Here is where Soto misses the calming influence of Judge in the dugout where Judge would basically reinforce Soto saying, “Hey, just be Juan.’’

Talking hitting in the dugout is a lost art and that is why it was fun to watch Soto last year in Pinstripes, it wasn’t a mad dash to the iPad. It was a conversation with teammates and coaches like Roessler of what just happened and what needs to happen the next time in the box.

They call it baseball.

That is how it was done for generations of players. That is the talk that is important. New York is the greatest for sports talk radio, too, where no good crisis is overlooked; that is all part of the landscape and I know having spent decades in the middle of that world. Have fun with it. When you sign a $765 million contract and leave the Yankees for the Mets, that money came with a bullseye on your back. If you try to be something you are not, New York will quickly let you know.

Soto needs to continue to talk pure baseball talk with the media while being Juan Soto in the box, controlling that narrative.

That’s part of the deal too and once he realizes that he will be the center of attention no matter what. He can learn to control the media narrative and get to that place where that Soto Smile does the talking for him, the same Soto Smile Yankee fans saw all last year; until that final out of the World Series when Soto immediately went into free agent mode, a big mistake.

That was the moment that officially ended the New York honeymoon.

Soto is married to the Mets for 15 years. Now show up and play your game. Mets fans will be Mets fans. Yankee fans will be Yankee fans. You be you.

Listen once again to your old protector Aaron Judge.

45+ years, columnist at NY Post for the last 23 years prior to joining BallNine. Elected to the NY Baseball Hall of Fame. Former SportsTalk Host (KFMB), ESPN’s First Take and Cold Pizza contributor. Frequent guest on radio shows and podcasts nationwide. Author of seven books. Seen in episode 10 of ESPN’s “The Last Dance” (the one with Dennis Rodman). First baseball interview he conducted was with Thurman Munson. Now you know why he is America’s Most Beloved Sportswriter.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register