f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 8, 2026 4:42 am PDT

The 1984 Major League Baseball All Star Game was awesome for many reasons. It featured 20 future Hall of Famers and the game itself had some juice. There was still a well-defined rivalry between the two leagues and the American League had won the game the year before for just the second time in a 20-year span. The rosters featured sure-fire Hall of Famers at the end of their careers, like Rod Carew and Reggie Jackson, established veteran superstars like George Brett, Dave Winfield and Rickey Henderson and upstart young phenoms like Dwight Gooden, Don Mattingly, Tony Gwynn and Darryl Strawberry.

What a cross section of talent.

The game was held in Candlestick Park and had a genuine San Francisco flavor to it. Huey Lewis and the News was on top of the music world as their album Sports had just reached number one and the San Francisco-based group performed the National Anthem. Airplanes from nearby Travis Air Force Base performed a flyover and the Presidio of San Francisco presented the colors.

Willie McCovey was the honorary captain for the National League and the first pitch ceremony was handled by two great Giants pitchers. The first was Stu Miller, who pitched for the Giants in both New York and San Francisco. Miller provided a great anecdote when the previous All-Star Game held at Candlestick Park took place in 1961. Miller was on the mound when a gust of wind at the famously breezy ballpark caused the 165-pound Miller to sway while he was in the set position, resulting in a balk. The story became embellished to paint a picture of Miller being blown clear off the mound as the years went on.

The second person involved in the first pitch ceremony was the headliner: an 81-year old Carl Hubbell. The Meal Ticket was on hand to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the 1934 All Star Game, which was also hosted by the Giants and held in the Polo Grounds. That game is famous for one of the greatest accomplishments in the sport’s history, even if it was done in an exhibition.

The 1934 All-Star Game may not have counted in the standings, but the teams competed as if it did. Hubbell was the starting pitcher and he was set to face an American League lineup that consisted entirely of future Hall of Famers. Hubbell ended up striking out six Hall of Famers in order—Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx, Al Simmons, Joe Cronin and Lefty Gomez. There was a single by Bill Dickey mixed in, but still, that’s a damn impressive gauntlet to run through.

When the Giants and Major League Baseball decided to honor Hubbell on the 50th anniversary for the event, even they couldn’t have foreseen a pretty incredible twist that happened on July 10, 1984.

The first pitcher out of the bullpen for the National League in the All-Star Game that night was Fernando Valenzuela, who like Hubbell, was a master of the screwball. Wouldn’t you know that Valenzuela struck out three Hall of Famers in order—Dave Winfield, Reggie Jackson and George Brett. Things were a little different in 1984, and Valenzuela came out of the game after that inning.

Valenzuela was relieved by Dwight Gooden, who proceeded to strikeout, in order, Lance Parrish, Chet Lemon and Alvin Davis. It wasn’t three more Hall of Famers, but three fine hitters regardless.

Pretty amazing that on the 50th anniversary of Carl Hubbell striking out six Hall of Famers in a row in the All-Star Game that Valenzuela and Gooden combined to strike out six in a row with an elderly Hubbell on hand to see it.

 

Before we move on to this week’s edition of The Stud 400, here’s a look at the last five entries as we count down the 400 greatest moments in Major League Baseball history:

65: Steve Carlton 27 wins (1972)

64: Ray Chapman killed (1920)

63: Miracle Mets Win World Series (1969)

62: The Jack Morris Game (1991)

61: “Totally Juiced” Sports Illustrated story (2002)

And now, here’s Episode LXXVI of The Stud 400.

Bob Gibson, 196860. Bob Gibson dominates (1968)

Fans today like to use the phrase “video game numbers” when a player generates eye-popping stats.

It’s an apt term, but what about players who go beyond that? We’re talking the absolute pinnacle of performance where the numbers make you say, “That couldn’t have happened.” Babe Ruth and Barry Bonds come to mind when you think of offensive players who put up incomprehensible numbers.

For pitchers, as far as The Stud 400 is concerned, the most insane pitching season took place in 1968 by the fearsome Bob Gibson. Let’s just dive into the numbers. Gibby went 22-9 with a preposterous 1.12 ERA, a post Dead Ball Era record. His 0.83 WHIP is still among the best in baseball history and he led the league with 268 strikeouts in 304 innings. Gibson started 34 games and completed 28 of them. Of those 28 complete games, 13 of them were shutouts.

Gibson wasn’t removed from the mound all season; the only time he came out of a game was when he was lifted for a pinch hitter. Incredibly, Gibson was just 3-5 through Memorial Day. He then topped the Mets in a complete game effort to start June and then twirled five straight shutouts, and shutouts in eight of his next 11 starts. His ERA had dropped to 0.96 by the end of July. There have been some incredible pitching seasons covered here in The Stud 400, but for our money, nobody tops Gibson’s 1968.


Carl Hubbell, 193459. Carl Hubbell K’s six Hall of Famers (1934)

The very first Major League All-Star Game was a success beyond what most had anticipated. It was meant to be a one-year event, but thanks to its huge popularity, a home run by Babe Ruth and a showcase that featured other immortals like Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx and Lefty Grove, it was agreed that the leagues would revisit the game in 1934.

That game turned out to be historic as well thanks to the great Carl Hubbell. Hubbell had the unenviable task of facing an American League lineup in which every single one of the nine starters landed in Cooperstown. We’re talking slam dunk Hall of Famers too. Hubbell himself was coming off a 1933 campaign in which he was named National League MVP and was no slouch himself. The saying goes that good pitching beats good hitting, and if you’re wondering whether that holds true when the hitters go by the names of Gehrig and Ruth, in the case of Hubbell, it did.

After giving up a single to Charlie Gehringer and a walk to Heinie Manush, Hubbell had the unenviable task of facing Ruth with no outs and two on. He made quick work of The Babe, striking him out on four pitches. Up next was Gehrig, who worked the count full. With the runners moving, Hubbell struck out the Iron Horse. He still had some work to do as the righty Foxx was up next with two runners in scoring position. Foxx worked the count to 2-2, but Hubbell struck him out too. Hubbell started the next inning by striking out Al Simmons and Joe Cronin, each on five pitches. If you’re counting, that’s now five straight future Hall of Famers struck out by The Meal Ticket. He got Bill Dickey to a 1-2 count as he looked to extend his streak, but Dickey hit a single. Hubbell finished the inning by striking out opposing pitcher Lefty Gomez, himself a Hall of Famer as well.

Great pitching beats great hitting, indeed.


Barry Bonds hits #7358. Barry Bonds #73 (2001)

Major League Baseball’s home run record used to be the most cherished single-season record in all of sports. That is until the steroid users came in and shit all over it.

We’re not going to deny that the great home run chase of 1998 was fantastic in real time, and having Roger Maris’ family present for it added to the aura. But after the excitement dwindled, Mark McGwire’s 70 and Sammy Sosa’s 66 homers felt dirty. We knew they were on steroids and to see them both blow past the cherished magic number of 61 kinda sucked when the dust settled. Three years later when Barry Bonds clubbed an inhuman 73 home runs, things were just preposterous. Bonds tied McGwire’s record in Game 159 and had a three-game series at home against the Dodgers to try to break the record. He didn’t leave the fans hanging too long as he smacked the record-breaking home run in his first at bat of the series. Bonds homered in his second at bat to give him 72 and then hit his final home run in his first at bat of the Giants last game of the season.

Bonds’ 73 home runs is a number likely not to be reached, even in this age of torpedo bats, juiced baseballs and pitchers with no command, but it’s a record that can’t be mentioned without the taint of steroids attached. It’s also why Maris’ 61 homer season is higher ranked in The Stud 400 even though Bonds beat it by 12.


Tom Seaver speaks after getting traded57. Mets trade Tom Seaver (1977)

Here’s a social experiment for you if you’re into that kind of stuff. Mention the phrase “Midnight Massacre” to any Mets fan over the age of 50 and see what happens. The responses you will get will include anger, head-shaking embarrassment, tears or a dead-man’s stare.

If you don’t get punched in the face, consider it a win. It’s the darkest night in franchise history; the night they did the impossible and traded away The Franchise, Tom Seaver. Seaver and Mets Chairman M. Donald Grant had been going through a long, contentious negotiation for a contract extension with Mets ownership doing its best to remain cheap and heartless throughout the process. The New York media, specifically Dick Young, played a role in Seaver’s decision-making as well, as they largely sided with Mets ownership in the debate. Baseball writer Maury Allen wrote a story about it and the headline attached read “Dick Young Ran Tom Seaver Out of Town.” It detailed that Young wrote two columns about Seaver that were very personal. He even mentioned jealousy between Seaver’s wife and Nolan Ryan’s wife. When things turned that personal, Allen said that Seaver decided he didn’t want to play in a media market where writers could and would drag family into the tabloids.

Late in the evening on June 15, 1977, the Mets shipped off Tom Seaver and Dave Kingman in two separate trades as they began a painful rebuild. In return for Seaver, the Mets got Pat Zachary, Steve Henderson, Doug Flynn and Dan Norman. None of them became any kind of difference maker for the Mets. They made some solid contributions to pretty atrocious teams, but you figured you’d get a little more for arguably the best pitcher the game has ever seen. Seaver was 32 years old at the time of the trade and he went 75-46 with a 3.18 ERA in six years with the Reds. He returned to the Mets as a 38-year-old in 1983 and then chased his 300th win in the late 1980s with the White Sox.

To this day, Seaver remains the preeminent player in Mets history. He exemplified greatness, class, competition and intelligence and, Goddammit, he never should have worn another uniform in his career.


56. Jackie Robinson’s #42 retired across MLB (1997)

There are some moments in baseball history that transcend the sport and Jackie Robinson’s debut might be at the top of the list.

Robinson is every bit an American hero as he is a baseball icon, so as much as baseball honored him over the years, it never seemed to be enough. He made his debut on April 15, 1947 and broke the color barrier in the process. When it came time to mark the 50th anniversary of that in 1997, Major League Baseball planned a ceremony at Shea Stadium in a game that featured the Mets and Dodgers. During the ceremony, Commissioner Bud Selig announced that Robinson’s number 42 would be retired across the entire sport. He became the first player in any sport to receive this honor. The NHL and NBA followed suit, retiring Wayne Gretzky’s 99 and Bill Russell’s number 6 league wide in 2000 and 2022, respectively.

Major Leaguers who were actively wearing number 42 at the time of the retirement were allowed to continue to wear it with Mariano Rivera the last to do so. Since then, Major League Baseball celebrates Jackie Robinson Day every April 15 and players across the sport don jerseys with the number 42 for that day only in a tribute to the iconic trailblazer.


Stay tuned for next week’s episode of The Stud 400 when we quite literally cover the entire timeline of baseball history in just one entry. We’re also celebrating the day that a group of the best players to ever play the sport finally got their due. We’re making a mad dash, going deep to left and dropping one of the magic numbers of the sport in an exciting installment of The Stud 400. Visit BallNine next week, if you could Hack it.

Rocco is a baseball writer with too much time on his hands who lives in the dusty corners of Baseball Reference. He was one half of the battery for the 1986 Belleville Recreation Farm League Champion Indians. He likes early 20th century baseball nicknames, pullover polyester jerseys and Old Hoss Radbourn. He works as a College Athletics Director and his second book was released in April of 2021.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register