f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 12, 2026 2:41 pm PDT

Lost

BY KEVIN KERNAN

The biggest casualty to baseball in 2025 is the death of the finer points of the game.

For those who know the game it is sad to watch.

For those who do not know, it is onto the next invented statistic.

When baseball is at its best it is a ballet both offensively and defensively, but that is not the case these days. If you really want to watch a baseball disaster in every sense of the word, watch Wednesday night’s seventh inning and then the top of the eighth inning in the Red Sox’ 8-4 loss to the Reds.

Hint: It was not exactly a replay of the 1975 World Series, although that is how the baseball marketers tried to play up the series.

The Red Sox played low-level Little League.

I can only imagine what Tito Francona had to say in private about his old team after they committed so many mental and physical errors.

Let’s get to the root cause of the issue, though, as they like to say.

Clearly, there is an incredible lack of focus in today’s MLB. Part of that is because there are no repercussions on any level for poor and mindless play. The two often go hand in hand.

Without repercussions there is no learning. Without learning, there is no discipline. Without discipline, there is no growth.

Those who run the game now are like those parents who always look the other way when their kids are misbehaving.

So, without repercussions, without learning, without discipline and without growth you get mistakes over and over again.

The broadcasters will often say, “Well, he’ll never make that mistake again.’’ In MLB lingo: Wanna bet?

Constructive criticism is out the window for the most part – although I must say it was  fun to watch the Padres and Phillies play this week, two teams who clearly respect their managers.

The broadcasters will often say, “Well, he’ll never make that mistake again.’’

In MLB lingo: Wanna bet?

Let’s bring back constructive criticism as a teaching tool to this soft generation of players.

“They’ve pushed out the teachers,’’ one top talent evaluator told BallNine on Thursday. “Common sense, all the little nuances of the game are not being taught because they have the Big Picture, the Big Tools, the exit velocity, the home run, the creating of numbers and statistics like ERA+ saying that somebody isn’t good is good – or xwOBA because somebody is not hitting, ‘Yeah, but his xwOBA is good.’

“He’s hitting .200, he bleeping stinks.’’

“What we’ve done is we have built a cocoon around these players, an inability to be critical,’’ the evaluator added. “We used to get graded on accepting constructive criticism. That is the only way you get better. Those people are there to help you so when they criticize you for doing something wrong, you can’t get your feelings hurt, they are trying to help you get better. Those in charge don’t ever want to be criticized, either. That’s why they build a cocoon around themselves, that is why they don’t talk to the media, they only talk to certain media, who ask them softball questions. Accepting constructive criticism is not part of our everyday life anymore.’’

The truth is that player will probably make that mistake again, but more importantly – and this is something Nerds can’t grasp – as a manager or coach you are NOT taking full advantage of a teaching moment. You are not only teaching the bonehead player on your team who was just thrown out by 10 feet at THIRD BASE (forever a baseball no-no, but is widely accepted in today’s no-knowledge game) for the first out of the inning on a Green Monster wall-ball double because the hitter, the Red Sox Romy Gonzalez in this case thought – I don’t know – he was invisible.

You are teaching all the players.

The play was right in front of Gonzalez in his home park and he still couldn’t figure it out. When you jump on his butt, as a coach or manager, you are teaching the rest of the team, too. “Hey, don’t be an idiot.’’

The “he’ll never make that mistake again’’ crowd is willing to see the same mistake made by 25 different players. It is pathetic. It is not coaching. And I’m done giving passes to managers. Gonzalez walked right past Alex Cora in the dugout after his mindless mistake in a one-run game and Cora never bothered to look his way as Gonzalez went down the tunnel to I’m sure go check the replay.

If you say something right there, either constructive or hot-tempered like forever how baseball has been played and managed, everybody gets the message, not just the dope who made the mistake. All players will then think:

“I don’t want to be called out for being an idiot.’’

But the game is too touchy-feely right now. No one wants to be embarrassed even though they make embarrassing plays over and over again. So, in the end, it is Alex Cora, who I know knows the game inside and out and had to be totally pissed off in that moment, who winds up being embarrassed.

The managers of today are all about cashing their checks and being puppets, it’s that simple. And that is because the Nerds running the teams run away from confrontation, just listen to how they speak.

The next inning, the top of the eighth, completely disintegrated on defense for the Red Sox: a misplayed pop fly, the left fielder Roman Anthony then overthrowing the ball to second from about 40 feet away because he babied the throw, next an error at shortstop by Trevor Story and then Marcelo Mayer picked up the ball and threw it to third baseman Abraham Toro who had zero awareness that the base-runner had overrun third base and was heading to home. Toro tried to apply a tag to the runner coming back to third even though that runner was already halfway to home having run through a stop sign, so by the time Toro threw home it was too late. Vintage Little League.

Reds analyst Jeff Brantley, a former pitcher, rightly called the inning “a supreme defensive breakdown’’ by the Red Sox. And did I mention that Christian Encarncion-Strand’s seventh inning grand slam was set up by a silly error by third baseman Toro on a high chopper when Toro tried to throw before he caught it?

Every mistake rolls into another mistake when nothing is said or done. And it is more than physical errors; it is more than mental errors. It is errors in judgement by those running teams.

The Nerds think anybody can play anywhere because they never played the game.

Toro is not a third baseman.

Just like the Yankees’ Jazz Chisholm is not a third baseman. I’m so tired of watching hot shots to third get past All That Jazz because he won’t put his body in front of the baseball a la real third basemen of the past like Graig Nettles.

There is a reason for that. Chisholm is a middle infielder. He is not a third baseman, but Brian Cashman’s Nerds have everyone playing everywhere. Like Ben Rice at catcher. The Blue Jays took full advantage of Rice’s defensive shortcomings, including the wild pitch with one knee down that scored what turned out to be the winning run on Wednesday.

More games are lost by trying to steal strikes than ever before. In each of the previous two games, Yankees catcher J.C. Escarra was hit with costly catcher’s interference calls trying to steal strikes.

Players don’t develop, just look at the continued mistakes made by Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe. At least David Cone, another former pitcher who prefers good defense behind him, said as much on the Yankee broadcast the other day.

I’m sure there were many other mindless mistakes in baseball over the last few days; I just don’t have the time or patience to watch them. And I’m sure many other managers, like Cora, looked the other way. I once watched Cora the player in the visiting clubhouse in Arizona being so upset over the actions of a teammate that as he stared at that teammate Cora literally walked into a wall.

And now you are telling me as manager, when his team self-destructs, he is looking the other way on his own.

Aaron Boone’s teams consistently make the same mistakes, year after year – and in some ways that Volpe blowup inning the other day was a miniature version of the Game 5 World Series fifth inning blowup.

Here we are nearly nine months later, and Yankee fans are watching the same nightmare with no repercussions from Boonie the Nickname Maker.

The finer points of the game have been lost under the current leadership of the game. It starts at the top with Rob Manfred’s willy-nilly silly rules.

“Let’s make the bases bigger like pizza boxes!’’

“Let’s have only three disengagements!’’

“Let’s go wild and create a fake baserunner, a fake double, just make it up, and stick him on second base in extra innings, the FRISP, the fake runner in scoring position!

“Let’s get the game over with, the players don’t want to be out there that long. The umpires don’t want to be there because I took away all their decision making. And I as commissioner, certainly don’t want to be stuck at a game all day, there are golf courses to be played.’’

As a result, the finer points of the game are all flushed down the MLB toilet. So, of course, the players are not going to pay attention to all the finer points of the game that made baseball America’s Game.

“Oh yeah, one other thing, let’s bet on every aspect of the game. It’s all Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson’s fault, anyway.’’

The finer points of the game have been replaced by point spreads. Forget about not making the first or third out at third base, what are the odds of that player hitting a triple? Go for it.

Just to make sure all the finer points of the game hit dinosaur status, get rid of the longtime teachers of the game who taught the next generation of teachers. Replace them with Nerd coaches who don’t know the game but can spreadsheet with the best of them. No teaching allowed … except launch angle, velocity, and spin.

One other thing, and this will be addressed Sunday in The Story here at BallNine, so mark your calendar: What happens when so many minor league teams are eliminated and what happens to one of those minor league towns, Batavia, N.Y.

Grassroots fans were told to get lost by MLB.

Just as the finer points of the game are being lost now.

45+ years, columnist at NY Post for the last 23 years prior to joining BallNine. Elected to the NY Baseball Hall of Fame. Former SportsTalk Host (KFMB), ESPN’s First Take and Cold Pizza contributor. Frequent guest on radio shows and podcasts nationwide. Author of seven books. Seen in episode 10 of ESPN’s “The Last Dance” (the one with Dennis Rodman). First baseball interview he conducted was with Thurman Munson. Now you know why he is America’s Most Beloved Sportswriter.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register