f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 17, 2026 5:30 pm PDT

First & Last VI

Every player who reaches the major leagues has a first game and a last game. Sometimes those games are one in the same. How did baseball’s immortals do in their first major league game? This is another installment in a series of Myster Eephus columns of the first and last games of MLB’s greatest players.

(Original Caption) Ed Matthews, Milwaukee Braves Third Baseman.

Eddie Mathews Sr. had an idea. Many clubs wanted to sign his son, Eddie Jr. His father suggested he go with the Boston Braves. Why? Their third baseman, Bob Elliott, was getting older, and the senior Mathews figured the team would soon have an opening at that position.

After two-plus seasons in the minors, Mathews beat out Elliott, then 35, to be the starting third sacker in 1952, when he was 20. He made his major league debut against the Brooklyn Dodgers on Opening Day, April 15 of that year.

In the bottom of the second, he drew a walk. With two outs he was on second when Billy Reed singled, but Mathews was thrown out at the plate. In his next two at-bats, he grounded out to Dodgers first baseman Gil Hodges.

The wind was blowing in from right field, and the Boston Globe reported the Braves’ left-handed hitters were frustrated when their drives fell short of the fences.

“Eddie Mathews, brilliant hitting rookie third baseman, unloaded with all his 195 pounds on a Roe pitch in the ninth inning, only to watch it drop harmlessly into the waiting arms of one Duke Snider,” the paper wrote. “It might not have gone out,” Mathews said later, “but it certainly would have been up against the fence.”

Mathews later called his father to tell him how his first game went.

The next day, he had his first hit, an infield single. In Philadelphia on April 19, with two on and the Braves trailing 7–3 in the top of the eighth, Mathews clubbed his first home run off Phillies pitcher Ken Heintzelman. The Braves won 9–7.

Mathews’ reputation as a power hitter was created before he played in Milwaukee, said Bob Buege, co-author with Mathews of Eddie Mathews and the National Pastime.

“When he was 18 years old, he hit a home run into a magnolia tree in Atlanta, and nobody ever hit a ball there except Babe Ruth, and Ruth did it on one bounce. So the only one to hit it on a fly was Eddie Mathews, so his reputation preceded him by at least a year,” said Buege.

(Buege said the tree, which stood in center field at Ponce de Leon Field, is still standing. The distance from home plate to the tree has been estimated to be between 462 and 500 feet and was in play until the outfield fence was moved in by 50 feet.)

Hank Aaron #44 and Eddie Mathews #4 of the Atlanta Braves look on from the dugout circa 1966. Hank Aaron played for the Atlanta Braves from 1954 to 1954 and Eddie Mathews played for the Braves from 1952 - 1966. (Photo by Louis Requena/MLB via Getty Images)

In his rookie season, Mathews batted .242 with 25 home runs and 58 RBIs.

Near the end of spring training in 1953, the Braves announced they were moving to Milwaukee, where there was no sophomore slump for the third sacker. He led the league with 47 home runs, drove in 135 runs, and batted .302.

Mathews grew up in California. According to a Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) biography by Bob Fleitz, when he was a boy his mother would pitch to him and said any ball hit to her right would mean extra chores. She said, “I’m going to make a pull hitter out of you.” Mathews threw right but batted left.

With Mathews, Henry Aaron, and Warren Spahn, the Braves won pennants in 1957 and 1958. They beat the Yankees in the first Series but lost to the Bronx Bombers the following year.

That core of players never won another pennant, despite Mathews’ slugging. Before turning 30, he swatted 370 home runs, but injuries to his back and drinking affected his hitting.

After playing a season and a half in Atlanta—making him the only Brave to play in three cities—Mathews was traded to Houston.

In San Francisco on July 14, 1967, he belted his 500th home run off Juan Marichal. A month later, Mathews was traded to the Detroit Tigers, and in 1968 he was playing in another World Series.

In Game One of the 1968 Fall Classic against the St. Louis Cardinals, Mathews pinch-hit for third baseman Don Wert, and Bob Gibson struck him out.

In Game Four, Mathews started at third and singled against Gibson in the bottom of the second.

It was his last hit and last game as a major leaguer. He managed the Braves for several years—including the game Aaron hit his 715th home run, passing Ruth. In 1978 he was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

(Original Caption) 4/12/1916-OPENING GAME OF THE NEW YORK AMERICANS AND THE WASHINGTON SENATORS. Photo shows Walter Johnson of the Washington Senators.

So, Walter Johnson was human after all. In 1920, he suffered from “a bad cold, a sore arm, and pulled leg muscles [that] limited him to an 8–10 mark in only 21 appearances,” according to a SABR biography by Charles Carey.

For a time, fans must have thought he was not human. In a four-game span in September 1908, he pitched three complete games, winning all three by shutout.

Like so many players in that time period, and up to maybe the 1950s, Johnson grew up on a farm. He began pitching in his teens, and after playing (and impressing) in industrial leagues and for an Idaho town team, he signed with the Washington Nationals (later Senators). He made his major league debut on Friday, August 2, 1907, against the Detroit Tigers. He gave up two runs, but he lost 3–2. Afterwards Ty Cobb said Johnson’s fastball “made me flinch” and “hissed with danger.”

The Detroit Free Press wrote Johnson “demonstrated conclusively that he is a pitcher of the first class by holding the Tigers to six hits in eight innings.” He struck out six and walked three.

The following year, Carey wrote: “With his pitching staff in shambles, manager Joe Cantillon sent the sturdy Johnson to the mound in New York for three consecutive starts over a four-day period. Walter didn’t disappoint, shutting out the Highlanders on six, four, and two hits, in a feat that electrified the baseball world.”

In Johnson’s final game, played on September 30, 1927, he was not on the mound but in the batter’s box. Trailing the Yankees at Yankee Stadium 4–2, with two outs, pitcher Tom Zachary was due to bat, but Johnson pinch-hit for him. He hit a fly ball to right field, where Babe Ruth caught it to end the game and Johnson’s career.

His last pitching performance was on September 22 in a start against the St. Louis Browns. He pitched 3.1 innings, gave up nine hits, six runs (five earned). Johnson struck out Frank O’Rourke leading off the third inning. It was his final K, number 3,509, a record that stood for many years.

(Original Caption) Kings of the Strikeout: When Walter Johnson (right) set a mark of 303 strikeouts for one season back in 1912, it apparently entered the books to stay. Anyhow, it is still there. The Dodgers' famous Dazzy Vance (left) came closest to that mark, whiffing 262 in 1924, his greatest year. Dazzy was named NL's MVP, baseball's No. 1 man, with a 28-6 record. (Photo by Hank Olen/NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images)

Johnson’s biggest adversary was his teammates. Washington was one of the worst franchises for most of Johnson’s career. He won a record 38 1–0 games. He also lost a record 26 1–0 games, another indication of unsupportive teammates.

According to Carey, Johnson planned to retire after the 1924 season, but Washington owner Clark Griffith finally assembled a team worthy of its pitching ace, and the Senators captured their first American League pennant. A rejuvenated Johnson was the key to their victory and was the league’s MVP. He had a 23–7 record and led the league in wins, ERA, strikeouts, and shutouts. In a seven-game World Series against the New York Giants, Johnson and his team had some luck. Starting in the ninth in a tie game, Johnson pitched four scoreless innings, and the Senators won the championship in the bottom of the 12th when a ground ball hit by Earl McNeely struck a pebble and bounced over the head of Giants third baseman Fred Lindstrom, allowing Muddy Ruel to score. Washington again won the pennant in 1925 but lost the World Series to Pittsburgh in seven games.

When he retired, Johnson had a record of 417 wins and 279 losses, 3,509 strikeouts, 110 shutouts, 12 20-win seasons, 11 seasons with an earned run average below 2.00, and an astounding 531 complete games in 666 starts.

He was also one of baseball’s best-hitting pitchers, having a lifetime batting average of .235. In 1925, he batted .433, and in his last year, at age 40, in 50 at-bats he hit .348.

He managed the Senators and then Cleveland for several years. His combined winning percentage was .550.

In 1936, he was among the first 12 inductees into the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.

Third Baseman Wade Boggs #26 of the Boston Red Sox before a game circa 1986 at Fenway Park in Boston, Massachusetts. Boggs played for the Red Sox from 1982-92. (Photo by Focus on Sport/Getty Images)

Wade Boggs thought he’d be a first-round draft choice but had to wait until the seventh round to be picked by the Sox in the 1976 draft. At Elmira in the New York–Penn League, he batted .263. In the next five seasons he batted .332, .311, .325, .306, and .335.

But he didn’t make the majors until 1982. He had a good spring training, batting .338, fourth best on the team. Boston, however, had Carney Lansford, who won the AL batting title in 1981, at third. The team also had Dave Stapleton at first base, who had a superior glove.

The Sox figured Boggs would be a valuable bench player; they even tried him in right field.

In The Boston Globe’s season preview, Peter Gammons wrote, “Rookie Wade Boggs looks like the reincarnation of Mike Hargrove.” A first baseman/outfielder, Hargrove hit above .300 his first two seasons in Texas, then .287, and batted .305 in his fourth season. He had little power but drew walks, and one year led the league in on-base percentage.

In discussing his bench, manager Ralph Houk told Gammons, “Boggs has impressed everyone; he can flat-out hit and he can help.”

He made his debut on April 10 in the second game of a doubleheader (and the second game of the season) at Memorial Stadium in Baltimore. Playing first base, he went 0-for-4. In his first at-bat he grounded back to the pitcher, Dennis Martínez. He also grounded out to the shortstop and second baseman, and in the ninth inning he grounded back to pitcher Sammy Stewart.

On April 14, Boggs pinch-hit for a teammate leading off the ninth inning with his team trailing 5–4. He flied out to left. Afterwards, Boggs didn’t appear in a game until April 26, when he started in the first game of a doubleheader against the Chicago White Sox. In the eighth inning, he had his first major league base hit when he singled off starter Rich Dotson. Houk sent Stapleton in to pinch-run for him.

Houk said he used Boggs “to get him some at-bats.”

Lansford batted .301 that season. Boggs, playing in 104 games, hit .349 in 382 at-bats.

In December of 1982, the Red Sox traded Lansford and two others to Oakland for outfielder Tony Armas and another player. But news coverage did not mention Boggs as the heir apparent at third.

In 1983, Boggs played every day and led the league by batting .361. The following year, he hit .325, then ran off four consecutive batting titles.

Wade Boggs #12 of the Tampa Bay Devils Rays hits his 3000th hit and second home run of the season in the sixth inning against the Cleveland Indians during a game at Tropicana Field on August 7, 1999 in St. Petersburg, Florida. (Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images)

But while the Red Sox made the playoffs during Boggs’ tenure, they never won a World Series. He batted above .300 from 1989–1991. Then at age 34 in 1992, he batted .259. After the season, the Red Sox offered him a two-year contract. He signed a three-year contract with the New York Yankees.

I asked a friend, Pete Filicetti, who grew up in Boston and still follows the Sox from his suburban Philadelphia home, how he felt when Boggs went to the “enemy” Yankees?

“Pissed off as usual,” he said. “One of the greatest of all time at his position. The fact that he went to the Yankees was another irritant… he also contributed to the Damn Yankees winning another World Series, but he did choose to enter the Baseball Hall of Fame as a Red Sox.”

With New York, he hit above .300 for four seasons, including 1996, when the Yankees won the World Series. He played the final two years of his career with Tampa Bay, where he lived.

On August 7, 1999, Boggs homered off Cleveland’s Chris Haney for his 3,000th hit.

His final game was August 27. He flied out to center in the second inning, grounded into a double play in the fourth, and hit into a fielder’s choice in the sixth inning. In the ninth, he walked and was replaced by a pinch-runner. It was his last at-bat in his last game because of a knee injury. He announced his retirement a few weeks later in November 1999. He retired with a lifetime batting average of .328.

Boggs was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2005.

“The only time the Hall of Fame ever came into my mind was probably the time I was rounding first going into second, when I hit my home run for my 3,000th hit. I thought, ‘Well, here’s my ticket. If anybody wants to vote for me for Cooperstown, then I’ve got the credentials to get in,’” he said.

Mike Piazza #31 of the New York Mets in action during a agme against the Milwaukee Brewers at Shea Stadium in Flushing, New York. The Mets defeated the Brewers 8-3. Mandatory Credit: David Seelig /Allsport

I wonder if Mike Piazza still has the copy of Ted Williams’ book The Science of Hitting that the Splendid Splinter gave to him when he was 16.

According to a SABR biography, after watching him hit, Williams inscribed his book, “To Mike, follow this book. As good as you look now, I’ll be asking you for tickets.”

It was hyperbole, but close enough to the truth. Piazza became one of the game’s best-hitting catchers.

He was a September call-up, making his debut with the Dodgers on September 1, 1992, facing the Chicago Cubs at Wrigley Field.

In his first at-bat, with a runner on second and one out in the top of the second, Piazza faced Chicago Cubs right-hander Mike Harkey. Piazza walked. In his next three times at the plate, he doubled in the fourth, singled in the sixth, and singled again in the eighth; the Dodgers were down 3–1, so manager Tommy Lasorda pinch-ran for him. The game went into the 13th inning, with the Dodgers winning 5–4.

“Piazza Brings Spice to Dodgers Victory” was the headline in the next day’s Los Angeles Times.

“Piazza, their top prospect… exceeding even his own advanced billing,” reported the paper. In addition to his perfect night at the plate, he threw out the one baserunner who attempted to steal on him.

It has been reported Piazza was Lasorda’s godson, but Lasorda was actually godfather to Piazza’s younger brother. The Piazza family and Lasorda grew up in Norristown, Pa., not far from Philadelphia.

Despite impressive high school stats, no college offered him a scholarship. He attended college baseball powerhouse the University of Miami but played little. He transferred to Miami-Dade Community College, and while he hit there, no colleges or scouts came forward with offers. He was too slow, they said, didn’t have a position, etc.

New York Mets' Mike Piazza (L) is congratulated by third base coach John Stearns (L) after Piazza hit a first inning home run driving in Edgardo Alfonzo on April 3, 2001 against the Atlanta Braves at Turner Field in Atlanta, Georgia. The Mets beat the Braves 6-4. (STEVE SCHAEFER/AFP via Getty Images)

Lasorda asked the Dodgers to draft him so he’d be on the baseball map and maybe a college would notice him. He was selected by the Dodgers in the 62nd round. No offers arrived, so Piazza played minor league ball. He had two decent seasons playing part-time in low A ball, then busted out at Bakersfield, Calif., when he hit 29 home runs with 80 RBIs. The following season he split between Double A and Triple A, hitting a combined 23 home runs and batting .350.

After his debut game, Piazza didn’t hit much. But he was ready for the majors the following year. Mike Scioscia, the Dodgers’ everyday catcher for a dozen years, retired after the 1992 season. Piazza responded to being the new backstop by hitting .318 with 35 home runs and 112 RBIs. He was the unanimous choice for the NL Rookie of the Year.

In the next four seasons, he batted above .300 (reaching .362 in 1997 and amassing 167 home runs in that period). He won the Silver Slugger Award for six straight seasons (and 10 overall; he also made 12 All-Star Games).

Then something strange happened. He was traded—twice in a week. The Dodgers sent him to the Florida Marlins in 1998, and a week later the Fish traded him to the New York Mets.

In his first four seasons with the Mets, he hit 147 home runs and batted above .300 three times. He played his last two seasons with San Diego and Oakland, signing with them as a free agent.

His final game was September 30, 2007, at age 39. He was the DH batting fifth for the Oakland Athletics against the Los Angeles Angels, who were managed by the man he replaced in the Dodgers’ lineup, Mike Scioscia. In his first three at-bats, Piazza lined to third, popped to right field, and struck out.

Leading off the ninth inning, Piazza singled off Chris Bootcheck. Shannon Stewart then pinch-ran for him.

“Piazza… left to a warm ovation after his ninth-inning single. While he will weigh his options this winter, Piazza’s career could be over, and he knows it,” reported a California newspaper.

Piazza hit 396 home runs while playing catcher, the most of any receiver in baseball history. He is followed by Carlton Fisk’s 351 and Johnny Bench’s 327.

In 2016, Mike Piazza was elected to the Hall of Fame on his third try, with 83.0 percent of the vote. Of all catchers in the Hall, only Mickey Cochrane and Bill Dickey had higher batting averages; Fisk and Yogi Berra had more hits; and only Berra and Bench had more RBIs.

I bet Piazza still has that inscribed copy of Williams’ book.

Jon Caroulis has been writing about baseball for more than 20 years. Many of his articles have been about "unusual" events or players. He is a graduate of Temple University.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register