f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 8, 2026 5:51 am PDT

Pinstripe Rubble

BY KEVIN KERNAN

Here is the thing.

Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman are way too comfortable in their jobs. Who can blame them?

They are not held accountable, certainly not by owner Hal Steinbrenner.

Boone and Cashman are way too comfortable even when opposing teams openly mock them at Yankee Stadium as Rays slugging third baseman Junior Caminero did: “Daaa Yankees lose!’’

I’m wondering if the Yankees’ new big-time investors Apollo Sports Capital with their $2.6 billion deal might have a say in the future mechanics of running the Yankees.

I’m wondering if they noticed that Cashman keeps bringing back Boone as Yankees manager even though Boone has delivered a 27-30 (.474 winning percentage) in the postseason and has taken the Yankees to the World Series once during his Kumbaya tenure.

That was back in 2024 and the Yankees were humiliated by the Dodgers in five games. The Dodgers haven’t stopping winning since. Those Dodgers were openly mocking the Yankees too just like Caminero did after a tremendous performance by the Rays, sweeping the Yankees away in three games in the ALDS. To make his scoreboard point, there stood Caminero at third base after the last out with an imaginary broom in his hands, one sweep, two sweeps, three sweeps.

C-ya Yankees.

Then in their champagne-soaked clubhouse the Rays mocked the Yankees with the Frank Sinatra song “New York, New York.’’

When all is said and done, the Rays with their paltry $113 million payroll embarrassed the Yankees with their $341 million payroll under Boone and Cashman. Somehow the Yankees never led one single inning.

But you know where the Rays outspend the Yankees tremendously? They outspend the Yankees in baseball capital. Their players are schooled to play the game right and their manager Kevin Cash holds them accountable and is always two or three steps ahead of Aaron Boone.

I guess Brian Cashman doesn’t see any of that or refuses to see it.

Yankees fans scream they have had enough of Boone and Cashman and their empty promises, yet they still fill up Yankee Stadium. Talk about empty promises.

Yankees management plays Yankee fans for the fool every single year, laughing all the way to the bank. And now, in 2026, with the windfall of all the many platforms to monetize games and all that gambling advertising money, the Yankees are making even more money than they did in the past.

Clearly, Hal Steinbrenner is not looking at the scoreboard results of the postseason: 17 years now without a World Series victory. Three in a row is so long ago.The Yankees are supposed to be Baseball Bullies, but stand up to them now and like any bully they simply melt away.

During the Boone-Cashman Era the Yankees are 1-8 in playoff series against teams with an equal or better regular-season record. Boone and Cashman were excited because they swept the tomato can Red Sox, who, if you can believe it, are run more poorly by Craig Breslow than the Yankees. And Red Sox ownership is laughing even harder at their fans than Yankees ownership is laughing at Yankee fans.

The Yankees are baseball’s version of the Ottoman Empire, once a dominant force across three continents; it collapsed due to administrative inefficiency and military setbacks.

Pinstripe Empire?

What kind of Empire have the Yankees become?

More like Pinstripe Rubble.

The Yankees are baseball’s version of the Ottoman Empire, once a dominant force across three continents; it collapsed due to administrative inefficiency and military setbacks.

In baseball terms that would mean, as an example, bringing back an ineffective Trent Grisham to play centerfield for a ridiculous $22 million price tag —and here is the military part of the setback, after watching Grisham struggle all year, the Yankees made the command military decision to bat Grisham at leadoff in the most important game of the season because it was an elimination game. Grisham hit .000 for the series.

That wrong decision, of course, meant Gladiator-like Ben Rice was left on deck as the Rays recorded the last out – a strikeout of Grisham, of course – and started to mock the Yankees. But Boone said there were no regrets about the decision. Maybe Cashman wanted to prove Grisham was worth $22 million.

That is just one example I am pulling out of my watching the Yankees since 1960 hat.

How about allowing Jazz Chisolm Jr. to go his own weird way all year, including playing second base with a lollipop in his mouth and putting up with his putrid play and mindless errors and wasted talent? Chisholm Jr. also hit a whopping .000 for the series.

Once Anthony Volpe got his act together, Chisholm should have been benched. No one in charge had the guts to make that decision. And that was a disservice to Chisholm; it might have woke him up, but Yankees brass did not have the courage to make that call.

Also, the shame of this season is not only the Yankees wasting tremendous pitching but also wasting an infusion of homegrown young talent. Bad job, Yankees.

And by allowing Jazz-E to be Jazz-E it came back to bite them in a big way, especially in the ALDS Game 2 fiasco, another huge crack in the baseball foundation that caused the collapse of this Pinstripe Empire. The Yankees committed four of the ugliest postseason errors you could imagine in the 5-2 loss, three in the first inning to set the tone.

And don’t get me started on how Giancarlo Stanton was used in the ALDS. Stanton is now a statue of the player he once was in his Marlins days.

Were there no voices in the Yankees brain trust who might stand up to Cashman and say, “Boss, he hasn’t played all year and we now expect him to hit, and hit the Rays pitchers? What are we doing here?’’

My baseball man in Carslbad, California has been telling me all year about the upcoming Yankee doom, and sometimes just to get him more animated I would take an opposing view. But as Carlsbad Coach wrapped up the latest collapse of the Yankee Empire on Thursday, he made these telling and substantial observations.

“Yankees autopsy is organizational failure,’’ he said. “It was there all season. It was masked by the Yankees having the best starting rotation in the AL, maybe baseball. They destroy bad teams, because bad teams commit errors and issue walks. In the playoffs they don’t face teams making errors and issuing walks. Net result is the Yankees don’t know how to manufacture runs without the opposing team’s help. Net result is they were the only team swept this round. Knowing how to play the game as a team is the failure that will continue unless they overhaul the organization.’’

Bingo!

The Rays know how to play the game. When you don’t have power, you have to figure out a different way to win. And they have done that. The final Yankee offensive numbers in this series were stated on Katie Sharp’s tremendous X account before the Pinstripe body was cold.

“Yankees in 2026 ALDS:

.130 BA

.192 OBP

.239 SLG

.431 OPS

Those stats are the lowest BA, OBP, SLG and OPS in any multi-game postseason series in franchise history.”

Solid numbers from Katie.

In crime-series fashion, if the investigating officer asks the medical examiner the time of the Yankees death, the wise-cracking M.E. leans forward over the body and says, “About seven months ago when the Yankees put this roster together and did not do the work required to get better.’’

Of course, in his postgame analysis, Boone rumbled along like he always does with platitudes and lack of insight with the usual kicker about how this disappointment is going to fuel the fire next season.

Save it, Boonie. Scoreboard. Same for Brian Cashman’s upcoming remarks on the disappointment of the (fill in the blank) season. I’ve heard them all too many times before, including injuries being to blame like Aaron Judge’s Lost Season, and I don’t need to hear it anymore.

I am not going to be one of those media types to make proclamations about “Boone must be fired! Cashman must be cut loose after all these years!”

Hey, if Hal Steinbrenner doesn’t care why should I care?

Same goes for so many Yankees fans I know, including BallNine founder Chris Vitali, who refused to become emotionally invested in this 2026 team because of past crushing disappointments.

At least The Boss, George Steinbrenner cared about his team and really cared about results. The Steinbrenners live in Tampa and for the lowly, impoverished Rays to beat the Yankees in such a belt to ass fashion would have really set George off in a big way.

The Boone-Cashman Yankees got what they deserved. Their lack of true baseball awareness and fine-tuning caused this.

The Rays work at baseball. They have a manager who out-thinks the other manager. They have the best pitching coach in Kyle Snyder who understands the mechanics of the pitching body and the pitching mind. Their player development people and coaches are the best in the business. Whatever you do well as a baseball player you will do better as a Ray.

Let me add one more thing. The Rays not only work at baseball as I just said, but the Rays live at baseball. There is a difference. And despite the huge financial advantage the Yankees have over the Rays, the Rays Empire is rising.

The Pinstripe Empire is once again rubble.

OG Tee Ad

45+ years, columnist at NY Post for the last 23 years prior to joining BallNine. Elected to the NY Baseball Hall of Fame. Former SportsTalk Host (KFMB), ESPN’s First Take and Cold Pizza contributor. Frequent guest on radio shows and podcasts nationwide. Author of seven books. Seen in episode 10 of ESPN’s “The Last Dance” (the one with Dennis Rodman). First baseball interview he conducted was with Thurman Munson. Now you know why he is America’s Most Beloved Sportswriter.

Comments
  • Aris Sakellaridis

    Right on as usual! If the Yanks had any sense they’d hire you as an advisor after reading this article.

    October 9, 2026
  • dan radison

    Sad but true.

    October 9, 2026
  • Nancy Ferraro

    Dear Kevin, As usual, such an amazing article! Of course, you are 100 percent correct.

    October 9, 2026
  • James Testani

    Great analysis

    October 9, 2026
  • Allan Schnoor

    Accurate!!! Need overhaul……..

    October 10, 2026
  • Bill Horan

    Disappointing, yes. Rubble, no.

    October 15, 2026
Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register