f

For Fans Who Should Know Better

Mudville Crew            Contact Us

Mudville: November 8, 2026 4:11 am PDT

Happy Days

BY KEVIN KERNAN

People still don’t get it.

They say they do, but they don’t. Even Baseball People don’t get it.

As the Brewers were finishing off the once Mighty Dodgers in a four-game sweep in the NLCS on Thursday night, John Smoltz said of the Brewers: “They play a different style of baseball.’’

No, they don’t.

What Small Market Milwaukee (SMM) plays is Baseball. BrewBall is Baseball. As a result, these are Happy Days once again in Milwaukee.

That is Baseball with a capital B. It is not a different style. It is how the game is meant to be played, how the game used to be played, with a manager in Pat Murphy who holds players accountable.

As one longtime baseball evaluator told BallNine on Friday, “We need more Pat Murphys, we don’t need any more Kumbaya managers.’’

Indeed.

The Brewers play The Game, and they hold their players accountable. That is the significant difference that no one seems to understand but here at BallNine, we have been banging the drums for pure baseball for years. That is what the Brewers play on a nightly basis and never more so than dumping the Padres in four games in the NLDS and then sweeping the Dodgers in the NLCS to go to the World Series for the first time in 44 years.

The Brewers blew past the NL West this October, winning seven of eight postseason games against the Padres and Dodgers, who were looking to win their third straight World Series. The $143 million payroll Brewers slayed two teams with a combined payroll of $563 million.

Some numbers to digest. The Brewers hit .250 against the Padres and held San Diego to a .181 batting average. The Brewers on-base percentage was .340. The Padres had a .278 on-base percentage.

The Brewers hit .250 against the Dodgers and held LA to a .185 average. The Brewers posted a .347 on-base percentage against the Dodgers. The Dodgers had a .270 on-base percentage.

Talk about consistency.

The Yankees owe the Brewers a debt of gratitude because the Core Four Yankees remain the last team to win three straight World Series, 1998, ’99 and 2000.

Plain and simple, the Brewers play Baseball.

And here is what the Nerds cannot grasp. Baseball can take many forms because it is a game of skill, development, intelligence, toughness, accountability and belief. There are many outcomes. And it is constantly changing, sometimes you need to bunt to win, sometimes you need to hit a home run. During the season, the Brewers hit 50 fewer home runs than the Dodgers but in the NLCS they out-homered them, 7-1.

There are only 11 teams with a lower payroll than the Brewers. The Brewers are the smallest market in baseball, yet they already have 110 victories this year and need four more to be the Last Team Standing, something that Murphy said has been the goal since Day 1 of spring training. The Brew Crew have never won a World Series.

If you play baseball the right way, the complete way, it doesn’t matter if you are Small Market.

After the sweep of the Dodgers, where the Brewers trailed in every game, Murphy, who was proclaimed The Last Manager here at BallNine in August, came up with the great line about his team of “gamers’’ beating future Hall of Famers.

That is the beauty of BrewBall. Do the little things right and the game rewards you. As I wrote in that August column, predicting the future: Pro tip to all Nerds running MLB teams. Hire more Pat Murphys.

For months I have said I was hoping for a Brewers-Rays Small Market World Series just to show baseball that it’s not only about payroll, but I am okay with a Brewers-Cleveland World Series. Here’s why.

I would call that the Bob Uecker World Series, as in “Major League’’ the movie. Uecker broadcast Brewers games for 54 years and stole the show in Major League playing the role of broadcaster Harry Doyle with lines like this: “Heywood leads the league in most offensive categories, including nose hair. When this guy sneezes, he looks like a party favor.’’

Now I could drop all kinds of quotes about the Brewers’ success and get all wordsmith on you, but I am not going to do that. Instead, there was a telling moment after the victory Thursday night on the field at Dodger Stadium that said it all for Baseball People and was not recognized by analytics lovers.

If you play baseball the right way, the complete way, it doesn’t matter if you are Small Market. It is not the Small Market that gets in the way of building a championship team, it is Small Minded Nerds that create problems.

Be Baseball First.

Listen to what Murphy said about light-hitting David Hamilton, a speedster who hit the cushion home run off Edwin Diaz to put the Brewers up, 6-4 in Game 4. This is what I mean when I talk about development and accountability.

Hamilton bats ninth. Then comes young slugger Jackson Chourio, the Brewers’ most dangerous hitter. Notice how the Brewers put their most dangerous hitter, Chourio, who hit a first-pitch home run in Game 3 off Blake Snell, at leadoff and not someone like Trent Grisham as the Yankees did.

There is always a method to Murphy’s madness, and he explained it after the clinching win.

“I told Hamilton, I said today you are going to put a bunt down because everybody in the league, they don’t even know Hamilton, he has never been a full-time player,’’ explained Murphy of Hamilton’s third inning bunt when the Brewers were trailing, 4-0.

“Even though he is an average bunter, he led the league in bunt hits because he tried it so much,’’ Murphy said. “You put a bunt down, I promise you, you will get pitches to hit the rest of the game. He bunted with two outs, nobody on, a terrible bunt, he’s not good at it yet, and they throw him out at first base by a step and a half. The next two at-bats he got pitches to hit because the pitcher’s mentality is ‘I just don’t want to get to Chourio, let me give (Hamilton) something.’ And when he clicked that ball the most surprised guy in the world was Diaz, ‘I thought you guys told me this guy can’t hit.’

“So, I believe that is part of the process.’’

It sure is part of the process. At least for the Brewers. The part of the process Nerds never will understand. First of all, Nerds never want to bunt, and if they do bunt by some miracle, it’s only for a specific purpose. Murphy was playing the Long Game with Hamilton, having him bunt early to set up situations for later in the game where he would get pitches to hit. In the fifth inning, Hamilton singled home a run off of Tyler Glasnow to make it 4-3. Then in the top of the ninth he hit that solo home run to put the Brewers up two runs off a center-cut pitch by Diaz.

Those are the little things that Murphy talked about with his Brewers in spring training when he said the Brewers, who got swept by the Dodgers in the 2025 NLCS, needed to learn “to thread the needle.’’

They had the talent, but they needed to thread the needle, and to do that you have to be precise. To win playoff baseball and get to the World Series, you have to be precise. Everything matters. Look at Jake Bauers who focused more on his balance in his hitting setup this year instead of lift and launch and became NLCS MVP with two of his biggest at-bats, one being a 12-pitch AB against Yoshinobu Yamamoto and an 11-pitch at-bat against Snell, where he hit a three-run home run. That is development at the major league level.

And did you catch the part where Murphy made it clear Hamilton is not a good bunter? Hamilton just got to the Brewers this year in a trade from the Red Sox, you can be sure he will be a better bunter in the future because the Brewers coach-up their players.

Same goes for the Rays and Guardians. The pendulum is swinging back ever so slightly on improving players through coaching not just looking at an iPad and reading metrics. And just to be clear, I spoke with a baseball man on Friday, who told me several stories of Pat Murphy, when he was the Milwaukee bench coach, reaming out players, a la Jim Leyland reaming out Barry Bonds, for fundamental mistakes.

You must hold players accountable, that is a huge part of the Brewers process. That is how you get team buy-in from everyone. Winners want to be held accountable.

Interesting to note too, that the three teams still standing all have what I consider veteran, mechanics-centered pitching coaches in Chris Hook with the Brewers, Carl Willis with the Guardians and Kyle Snyder with the Rays.

The Brewers are having a magical October, but so is baseball, because BrewBall is all about playing Baseball with a capital B. The Small Market Brewers are playing large —and what a refreshing October this has become for MLB.

Happy Days in Milwaukee.

OG Tee Ad

45+ years, columnist at NY Post for the last 23 years prior to joining BallNine. Elected to the NY Baseball Hall of Fame. Former SportsTalk Host (KFMB), ESPN’s First Take and Cold Pizza contributor. Frequent guest on radio shows and podcasts nationwide. Author of seven books. Seen in episode 10 of ESPN’s “The Last Dance” (the one with Dennis Rodman). First baseball interview he conducted was with Thurman Munson. Now you know why he is America’s Most Beloved Sportswriter.

Post a Comment

You don't have permission to register